preloader image

Loading...

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

Madras High Court Awaits Division Bench Decision on Plea Seeking FIR in Alleged AI-Generated Books Procurement Scam

Madras High Court Awaits Division Bench Decision on Plea Seeking FIR in Alleged AI-Generated Books Procurement Scam

Introduction:

The Madras High Court has decided to await the outcome of proceedings before a Division Bench before passing orders on a petition seeking registration of an FIR and an investigation into the alleged procurement scam involving AI-generated books for the Periyar Arivulagu Library in Coimbatore. Justice V. Lakshminarayanan observed that since a Division Bench comprising Justice G.R. Swaminathan and Justice M.D. Sumathi was already considering a contempt petition connected with the same controversy, it would be appropriate to await the directions issued by that Bench before proceeding with the matter.

The petition was filed by I. Paranthaman, Joint Secretary of the DMK Legal Wing, who sought directions in connection with allegations that fabricated or AI-generated books had been procured for the library. The controversy concerns the procurement of books allegedly supplied by Agal Vilakku Publishers and the circumstances in which those books were selected, purchased and entered into the library’s records.

Paranthaman submitted that he had lodged a detailed complaint on November 7 before the Director of the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC), requesting the registration of a criminal case and a comprehensive investigation. He also sought immediate preservation of the relevant procurement documents, including files, note files, purchase orders, delivery records, accession registers and payment records. According to him, securing these documents at the earliest was necessary to prevent their alteration, manipulation or destruction.

The petitioner contended that the allegations surrounding the procurement had generated considerable public controversy and that accusations were being made against the previous Government without a proper investigation. He maintained that an impartial inquiry by the statutory anti-corruption agency was necessary to establish the facts, identify the persons actually responsible and distinguish genuine evidence from fabricated material circulated online.

When the matter came up before Justice Lakshminarayanan, Additional Public Prosecutor Arun Anbumani informed the Court that the DVAC had already registered an FIR pursuant to directions issued by the Division Bench. The State further submitted that the owner of Agal Vilakku Publishers, described as the primary accused in supplying the allegedly fabricated books, had been arrested. On that basis, the prosecution argued that the petition seeking registration of an FIR had become infructuous.

The Court, however, questioned whether registration of the FIR and arrest of one person were sufficient to address the larger allegations. The Bench sought to know what progress had been made in the investigation and whether the alleged supplier had independently placed the books in the library without any corresponding procurement or purchase process. The questions reflected the need to examine the entire chain of events rather than limiting the investigation to the person who allegedly supplied the books.

Upon being informed that the Division Bench sitting at Madurai was scheduled to consider the connected contempt petition the following day, Justice Lakshminarayanan decided to defer further consideration of the petition until Monday. The Court observed that if the Division Bench directed that the investigation be monitored, the single judge could pass appropriate orders in light of those directions.

The matter raises important questions concerning the scope of judicial intervention in alleged public procurement irregularities, the responsibility of vigilance authorities to investigate complaints of corruption and the need to preserve official records when allegations involve possible manipulation of procurement documents. It also highlights the importance of coordination between different Benches of the same High Court when connected proceedings concerning the same controversy are pending before them.

At this stage, the High Court has not determined whether the alleged procurement irregularities occurred or who may ultimately be responsible. Its immediate concern is to avoid passing an order that could conflict with or overlap with the directions of the Division Bench already seized of the connected proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties:

The petitioner, I. Paranthaman, approached the Madras High Court seeking intervention in relation to the alleged procurement of AI-generated books for the Periyar Arivulagu Library in Coimbatore. His principal concern was that the allegations required a formal criminal investigation by the DVAC and that the relevant official records needed to be secured without delay.

Paranthaman submitted that he had already addressed a detailed complaint dated November 7 to the Director of the DVAC. Through the complaint, he requested the agency to register a criminal case, investigate the alleged irregularities and take appropriate legal action against everyone found responsible.

A significant part of the petitioner’s request concerned the preservation of documentary evidence. He specifically sought the securing of procurement files, note files, purchase orders, delivery records, accession registers and payment records. These documents, according to him, were essential to reconstruct the procurement process and establish how the books had been ordered, supplied, received and entered into the library’s records.

The petitioner expressed concern that unless the authorities acted promptly, the relevant documents could be altered, manipulated or destroyed, thereby affecting the possibility of a fair investigation. The request for preservation was therefore not merely incidental to the demand for registration of an FIR; it was presented as an essential step towards protecting the evidence necessary to determine the truth.

He also referred to the public controversy surrounding the alleged procurement. According to his submission, allegations were being circulated against the previous Government without a proper investigation. Such accusations, he argued, could not be conclusively accepted without an impartial examination of the underlying records.

The petitioner maintained that the DVAC, as the statutory anti-corruption agency, was the appropriate authority to investigate the allegations, identify those actually responsible and determine whether documents circulated online were genuine or fabricated. The investigation, according to him, should establish the complete factual position rather than allow public allegations to substitute for verified findings.

The State, represented by Additional Public Prosecutor Arun Anbumani, opposed the need for a further direction on the ground that the principal relief sought in the petition had already been acted upon.

The prosecutor informed the Court that the DVAC had registered an FIR pursuant to the directions of the Division Bench. He further submitted that the owner of Agal Vilakku Publishers, who was identified as the primary accused in connection with the alleged supply of fabricated books, had been arrested.

On this basis, the State contended that the petition had become infructuous because the requested criminal case had already been registered. The prosecution’s position was that the immediate relief sought by the petitioner had effectively been granted through the registration of the FIR and the subsequent arrest.

However, the Court questioned whether these steps adequately addressed the wider issues raised in the petition. It asked the State what progress had been made following the registration of the FIR and whether the investigation had examined the role of other persons involved in the procurement process.

The Judge specifically questioned whether the arrested publisher could have supplied the books independently without anyone purchasing or authorising their procurement. The Court also referred to the practical question of whether an individual could simply place books in a public library, such as the Connemara Public Library, without any corresponding institutional process.

These questions brought the focus back to the larger procurement mechanism. The controversy was not confined to the identity of the alleged supplier but also concerned the circumstances in which the books were purchased, the officials or other persons involved in the process, and the records supporting the transactions.

When the State informed the Court that the connected contempt petition was scheduled to be heard by the Madurai Division Bench the following day, the single judge decided that the matter should be taken up again after that hearing.

Court’s Judgment:

Justice V. Lakshminarayanan did not pass a final order on the petition seeking registration of an FIR. Instead, the Court decided to await the decision of the Division Bench comprising Justice G.R. Swaminathan and Justice M.D. Sumathi, which was already dealing with a contempt petition arising out of the same controversy.

The central consideration behind the decision was the need to ensure judicial consistency and avoid passing an order that might overlap with or contradict directions issued by the Division Bench.

The Judge observed that since the connected matter was listed before the Division Bench the following day, it would be proper for the single judge to await the outcome of those proceedings. He indicated that if the Division Bench passed an order directing the monitoring of the investigation, the single judge would thereafter consider passing appropriate orders in the petition before him.

The Court stated:

“As the matter is listed tomorrow, it would be only proper for this court to await the decision taken by the division bench. In the event the division bench passes an order to monitor the investigation, this court, being a single judge, would pass appropriate orders at that time,”

This observation demonstrates that the Court was conscious of the fact that the same controversy was already receiving judicial attention before another Bench of the High Court. Rather than independently issuing directions without considering the proceedings already pending before the Division Bench, the single judge considered it appropriate to first ascertain the course adopted by that Bench.

Registration of an FIR does not necessarily conclude the issue

One of the most significant aspects of the hearing was the Court’s response to the State’s submission that the petition had become infructuous following registration of the FIR and arrest of the publisher.

The State had argued that the principal relief sought by Paranthaman was the registration of a criminal case, and that the DVAC had already taken that step. However, the Judge questioned whether the registration of an FIR and the arrest of one accused were sufficient to address the full scope of the allegations.

The Court’s questions focused on the procurement process itself. It asked whether the alleged supplier could have delivered the books without any person or authority purchasing them. The Judge also drew attention to the ordinary functioning of public libraries by questioning whether anyone could simply enter a library and place books there without an authorised process.

These observations were important because they highlighted that an alleged irregularity in public procurement may involve several stages and potentially multiple persons. Identifying the supplier alone may not explain how the books came to be procured, who approved the purchase, what documentation supported the transaction or how the books were accepted and recorded.

The Court’s questions therefore indicated that the investigation would need to examine the broader circumstances surrounding the alleged procurement rather than focus exclusively on the person who supplied the books.

However, these questions should not be treated as findings that any particular official or individual was involved in wrongdoing. The Court was examining the adequacy and scope of the investigation at a preliminary stage, not determining criminal liability.

Importance of examining the entire procurement chain

The controversy concerns books allegedly generated using artificial intelligence and procured for a public library. In such a matter, the relevant factual inquiry may extend beyond whether the books were actually supplied by a particular publisher.

The procurement records identified by the petitioner could potentially help establish the sequence of events, including the initiation of the purchase, the approval process, the issuance of purchase orders, delivery and receipt of the books, their entry into the accession register and the release of public funds.

The Court’s questions reflected the importance of examining these connected stages. If books were purchased using public funds, the investigation would necessarily have to consider the records showing who authorised the expenditure and under what circumstances the material was accepted by the institution.

The petitioner’s request to secure the procurement files, note files, purchase orders, delivery records, accession registers and payment records was therefore relevant to the broader allegations. Such records could assist investigators in determining whether the procurement followed the applicable procedure and whether any irregularities occurred.

Nevertheless, the High Court did not make any specific finding on the authenticity of the books, the genuineness of the documents or the involvement of particular public officials. Those matters remain subject to investigation and further judicial consideration.

Coordination between the Single Judge and Division Bench

Another important feature of the proceedings was the Court’s decision to defer its consideration because the Division Bench was already hearing a contempt petition connected with the alleged scam.

The Division Bench, comprising Justice G.R. Swaminathan and Justice M.D. Sumathi, was scheduled to take up the contempt proceedings at Madurai. The State informed the single judge that the FIR had been registered pursuant to the Division Bench’s directions and that an arrest had also been made.

In these circumstances, the single judge considered it appropriate to await the Division Bench’s decision before issuing any further directions. The approach reflects the importance of judicial coordination, particularly when proceedings arising from the same factual controversy are pending before different Benches of the same Court.

If the Division Bench were to direct monitoring of the investigation, the single judge would have to consider the petition in light of those directions. Passing an independent order without first ascertaining the Division Bench’s decision could potentially result in overlapping judicial directions.

The single judge therefore decided that the matter should be taken up on Monday, after the Division Bench had considered the contempt petition. The Court also asked the counsel appearing in the matter to inform the Division Bench about the pendency of the present petition.

The Judge made it clear that if the Division Bench permitted the matter to proceed independently, the single judge would consider the petition and pass appropriate orders.

No final determination on the alleged scam

It is important to distinguish the Court’s decision to defer the hearing from a final adjudication of the allegations. The High Court did not dismiss the petition as infructuous merely because the State had registered an FIR. Nor did it issue a final direction monitoring the investigation at this stage.

Instead, it kept the matter for further consideration after the connected Division Bench proceedings. The question whether the investigation requires additional judicial directions therefore remains open.

Similarly, the arrest of the owner of Agal Vilakku Publishers does not establish the guilt of the accused. The allegations concerning the supply of fabricated books, the procurement process and the possible involvement of others must be established through the investigation and, where necessary, subsequent judicial proceedings.

The matter also illustrates the distinction between registering a criminal case and conducting an effective investigation. Registration of an FIR initiates the criminal investigation, but the actual task of determining the facts may require examination of documents, transactions, approvals and the conduct of everyone connected with the procurement.

The Court’s questions underscored that the investigation should not be viewed as complete merely because the alleged supplier had been arrested. The wider circumstances surrounding the purchase and acceptance of the books remain relevant to the controversy.

Ultimately, Justice V. Lakshminarayanan decided to await the Division Bench’s decision on the contempt petition before passing further orders on Paranthaman’s plea. The matter was directed to be taken up on Monday, with counsel asked to bring the pending petition to the Division Bench’s attention. The Court thus left the question of further judicial intervention open, making clear that appropriate orders could be considered depending on the directions issued by the Division Bench.