Introduction:
The Kerala High Court, through a detailed and principle driven judgment, has once again underscored the constitutional mandate that the grounds of arrest must be effectively communicated to an accused, particularly in cases under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act. The ruling came in a bail application filed by Kamal Kumar Mandal, a native of West Bengal, who was arrested and prosecuted for alleged possession of commercial quantity of contraband under Sections 22(b)(ii)(C) and 8(c) of the NDPS Act. The case was heard by Dr Justice Kauser Edappagath, who undertook an extensive survey of binding precedents of the Supreme Court and the Kerala High Court to crystallize the law governing communication of grounds of arrest. While reiterating that specification of the quantity of contraband is mandatory for effective communication in NDPS cases and that failure to do so would render the arrest illegal, the Court ultimately dismissed the bail application on facts, holding that the requirement had been substantially complied with in the present case.
Arguments on Behalf of the Petitioner:
The accused petitioner challenged the legality of his arrest primarily on constitutional grounds. It was contended that the arrest was vitiated due to non compliance with Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India, which mandates that every person arrested must be informed of the grounds of arrest as soon as possible. The petitioner submitted that he was a native of West Bengal and did not understand either Malayalam or English. However, the arrest memo was prepared in English and Malayalam, and the intimation sent to his relatives was also in Malayalam, thereby rendering the communication ineffective and illusory.
The petitioner argued that in NDPS cases, the communication of grounds of arrest assumes heightened significance because the rigours of Section 37 impose strict limitations on grant of bail. It was submitted that unless the accused is informed of the exact nature of the accusation, including the quantity of contraband seized, he is deprived of the opportunity to effectively exercise his right to challenge the arrest and seek legal remedies.
Reliance was placed on a catena of judgments of the Supreme Court, including Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India, Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) and Vihaan Kumar v. State of Haryana, which laid down that grounds of arrest must be communicated in writing and in a language understood by the arrestee. The petitioner further relied on judgments of the Kerala High Court, such as Yazin S. v. State of Kerala and Rayees R.M. v. State of Kerala, which applied these principles specifically in the context of NDPS offences.
It was further contended that mere recording of grounds in official documents or seizure mahazars without ensuring that the accused understands them does not satisfy the constitutional requirement. According to the petitioner, since the alleged non communication goes to the root of the arrest, the arrest itself was illegal and the accused was entitled to be released on bail forthwith.
Arguments on Behalf of the State:
Opposing the bail application, the learned Senior Public Prosecutor submitted that the petitioner was involved in a serious NDPS offence involving commercial quantity of ganja weighing 23.4 kilograms. It was argued that there were prima facie materials connecting the accused to the crime, including seizure of contraband and contemporaneous documentation prepared at the time of arrest.
On the issue of communication of grounds of arrest, the State contended that there was substantial compliance with the constitutional mandate. The prosecution pointed out that the seizure mahazar clearly recorded that the grounds of arrest were communicated to the accused at the time of arrest itself. It was further submitted that the arresting officer had informed the accused’s father over the telephone regarding the arrest and the nature of the allegations.
The State relied upon the judgment in Mihir Rajesh Shah v. State of Maharashtra, which clarified that the requirement of written communication of grounds of arrest would operate prospectively. Since the arrest in the present case had taken place prior to the pronouncement of that judgment, the State argued that the petitioner could not claim its benefit.
It was also submitted that the petitioner had not demonstrated any prejudice caused to him on account of the alleged non communication. The prosecution maintained that the arrest was lawful, the remand valid, and that the stringent conditions for bail under the NDPS Act were not satisfied.
Court’s Judgment:
Justice Kauser Edappagath commenced the analysis by reiterating the constitutional and statutory framework governing arrest. The Court undertook a comprehensive review of Supreme Court and High Court precedents and distilled the governing principles relating to communication of grounds of arrest. The Court categorically held that the constitutional requirement of informing an arrestee of the grounds of arrest is mandatory in all offences, including those under special statutes like the NDPS Act. It was reiterated that such grounds must ordinarily be communicated in writing and in a language understood by the arrestee.
Significantly, the Court reaffirmed that in NDPS cases, specification of the quantity of contraband seized is mandatory for effective communication of the grounds of arrest. Non compliance with this requirement would render the arrest and subsequent remand illegal, entitling the accused to immediate release. The burden, the Court held, lies squarely on the prosecution to establish that proper communication was effected, and subsequent filing of charge sheet or taking of cognizance cannot cure an unconstitutional arrest.
However, when the Court examined the facts of the present case, it found that the principles, though firmly reiterated, did not come to the aid of the petitioner. The Court noted that the seizure mahazar contained a clear recital that the grounds of arrest were communicated to the accused at the time of arrest. It also recorded that the accused’s father was informed over the telephone regarding the arrest and the allegations.
The Court further observed that the decision in Mihir Rajesh Shah, which mandated written communication of grounds of arrest in the language understood by the accused, was to operate prospectively. Since the arrest in the present case was prior to that judgment, the stricter requirement could not be retroactively applied.
While acknowledging that there were prima facie materials connecting the accused to the crime, the Court balanced the constitutional safeguards with the factual matrix and concluded that the requirement of communication of grounds of arrest had been sufficiently satisfied. Consequently, the arrest could not be held illegal on the facts of the case.
In view of the seriousness of the offence, the commercial quantity involved, and the compliance with arrest requirements, the Court dismissed the bail application.