Introduction:
The Delhi High Court, in Okoli Anayo Franklin v. The State (NCT of Delhi) (BAIL APPLN. 4027/2025), examined the scope and rigour of bail under Section 37 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, particularly addressing whether the absconding status of a co-accused can influence the court’s decision on bail. The case arose from the recovery of 256 grams of heroin, a commercial quantity under the NDPS Act, from a transaction allegedly involving multiple accused persons, one of whom, after being granted bail, jumped bail and became untraceable. The applicant, a foreign national, sought regular bail contending lack of direct evidence and prolonged custody. Justice Saurabh Banerjee, while dismissing the application, reiterated the stringent statutory framework governing NDPS bail and emphasized that the conduct of co-accused, especially abscondence after grant of bail, is a relevant and weighty circumstance while assessing the likelihood of the applicant fleeing from justice and re-offending, thus reinforcing the preventive philosophy underlying Section 37 of the NDPS Act.
Arguments of the Applicant (Accused):
The applicant argued that he had been falsely implicated in the case and that the recovery of heroin did not conclusively establish his conscious possession or direct involvement in the alleged offence. It was contended that there was no photographic or videographic evidence to link him decisively to the seizure of 256 grams of heroin, and that the prosecution case relied heavily on circumstantial material and statements of officials. The defence submitted that mere association with the alleged transaction could not automatically attract the rigours of Section 37 NDPS Act, especially when the evidentiary foundation was still under trial and only two out of nineteen prosecution witnesses had been examined. The applicant further pleaded that continued incarceration would amount to pre-trial punishment, violating his right to personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution. Stress was also laid on the absence of inordinate delay attributable to the applicant, and it was argued that the presumption of innocence must operate until guilt is proved beyond reasonable doubt. With respect to the absconding co-accused, the applicant contended that the misconduct of another accused should not be mechanically attributed to him, and that each bail application must be assessed on its own merits. Being a foreign national, the applicant assured the Court of cooperation with the trial process and undertook not to abscond or tamper with evidence if released on bail.
Arguments of the Prosecution / State:
Opposing the bail plea, the State submitted that the offence involved a commercial quantity of heroin, thereby squarely attracting the stringent twin conditions under Section 37 of the NDPS Act. It was argued that unless the Court is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds to believe that the accused is not guilty and that he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail, no relief can be granted. The prosecution highlighted that the applicant had committed the present offence while already on bail in another NDPS case, clearly demonstrating a continuing pattern of criminal conduct and disregard for the law. The State strongly emphasized that one of the co-accused, after being enlarged on bail, had absconded and was now facing non-bailable warrants, which raised serious concerns about the possibility of the applicant also fleeing from justice, particularly considering his status as a foreign national. The prosecution further argued that the trial was progressing and there was no inordinate delay warranting bail on humanitarian or constitutional grounds. It was submitted that the absence of photographic or videographic evidence did not dilute the prosecution case at the bail stage, as NDPS cases often rely on official witnesses and recovery memos, the veracity of which must be tested during trial.
Court’s Judgment and Reasoning:
The Delhi High Court, after carefully examining the rival submissions and the material on record, refused to grant bail to the applicant. Justice Saurabh Banerjee reiterated that bail under the NDPS Act stands on a distinct and far more rigorous footing than bail under ordinary criminal law. The Court emphasized that Section 37 embodies a clear legislative intent to curb drug trafficking by placing strict limitations on judicial discretion in granting bail, particularly in cases involving commercial quantities. Applying the twin conditions of Section 37, the Court held that the applicant failed to demonstrate reasonable grounds to believe that he was not guilty of the offence. On the contrary, the fact that the applicant allegedly committed the present offence while already on bail in another NDPS case strongly militated against him and indicated a pattern of repeated involvement in narcotic offences. The Court gave significant weight to the fact that a co-accused, after being granted bail, had absconded and was untraceable, resulting in the issuance of non-bailable warrants. It held that such conduct of a co-accused is a vital and relevant factor while assessing the likelihood of the applicant fleeing from justice, especially when the applicant himself is a foreign national with comparatively weaker local roots. The Court categorically observed that the absence of photographic or videographic evidence cannot, by itself, be a ground for bail when statutory presumptions and recovery of commercial quantity are in play. Noting that only two out of nineteen prosecution witnesses had been examined and that there was no allegation of deliberate delay by the prosecution, the Court concluded that this was not a fit case for grant of bail. Accordingly, the bail application was dismissed.