preloader image

Loading...

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

Consensual Relationships Cannot Be Criminalised After Breakdown Punjab and Haryana High Court Draws Clear Line Between Rape and Failed Romance

Consensual Relationships Cannot Be Criminalised After Breakdown Punjab and Haryana High Court Draws Clear Line Between Rape and Failed Romance

Introduction:

The Punjab and Haryana High Court, in a significant judgment addressing the growing tendency to criminalise failed personal relationships, quashed a First Information Report registered under Sections 376 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code, holding that a consensual relationship between two adults which does not culminate in marriage due to incompatibility or temperamental differences cannot be converted into a criminal prosecution. The petition was filed by XXX, invoking the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, seeking quashing of the FIR, the chargesheet, and the order dismissing his discharge application. The FIR had been lodged by XXX, alleging that she had entered into a physical relationship with the petitioner on a false promise of marriage and was later deceived when the petitioner refused to marry her. Justice Alok Jain, after examining the record and the settled principles governing offences under Section 376 IPC, held that the continuation of criminal proceedings in such circumstances would amount to an abuse of the process of law and quashed the FIR and all consequential proceedings.

Arguments on Behalf of the Petitioner:

The counsel for the petitioner submitted that the FIR was a classic example of a consensual relationship being retrospectively coloured as a criminal offence solely because it did not end in marriage. It was argued that both the petitioner and the complainant were major, educated, and fully conscious of the nature and consequences of their relationship at the relevant time. The relationship, it was submitted, was voluntary, mutual, and consensual, without any element of force, coercion, threat, or deception at its inception.

The petitioner’s counsel emphasized that there was no false promise of marriage at the beginning of the relationship. On the contrary, the bona fides of the petitioner were demonstrated by the fact that a roka ceremony had been performed between the families, indicating a genuine intention to marry. The relationship later deteriorated due to temperamental differences, particularly after the petitioner was posted in a sensitive area, which led to practical and emotional difficulties between the parties.

It was argued that the law is well settled that a promise to marry which subsequently fails due to intervening circumstances or incompatibility does not amount to a false promise so as to attract Section 376 IPC. The petitioner submitted that the complainant, after the breakdown of the relationship, attempted to exert pressure by making repeated complaints and ultimately lodging the present FIR to compel the petitioner into marriage.

The counsel further contended that the ingredients of rape were conspicuously absent from the FIR. There were no allegations suggesting that consent was obtained by deception at the inception, nor were there allegations of sexual intercourse against the will of the complainant. It was argued that permitting the prosecution to continue would amount to allowing criminal law to be used as a weapon for vengeance arising out of a failed relationship.

Arguments on Behalf of the Complainant and the State:

Opposing the petition, counsel appearing for the complainant submitted that the petitioner had enticed her into a physical relationship by assuring her of marriage and later withdrew his commitment, thereby exploiting her emotionally and physically. It was argued that the complainant consented to the physical relationship only because of the assurance of marriage and that once the promise was breached, the consent stood vitiated.

The complainant’s counsel submitted that the petitioner’s refusal to marry her after entering into a long term intimate relationship caused severe mental trauma and humiliation, and therefore the offence under Section 376 IPC was clearly attracted. It was argued that the conduct of the petitioner amounted to cheating and sexual exploitation under the guise of a false promise.

The State supported the complainant’s stand and argued that the FIR and the investigation material disclosed a prima facie case. The learned Assistant Advocate General submitted that while exercising jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC, the High Court should not conduct a mini trial or appreciate evidence, and that disputed questions of fact ought to be left for determination during trial.

It was further contended that whether the promise of marriage was false from inception or subsequently breached was a matter of evidence and intention, which could only be conclusively determined after recording evidence. Therefore, the State urged the Court not to interfere at the threshold.

Court’s Judgment:

After hearing the parties and perusing the record, the Punjab and Haryana High Court held that the FIR was liable to be quashed as it did not disclose the essential ingredients of offences under Sections 376 or 420 IPC. Justice Alok Jain observed that the material on record clearly showed that both parties were major and were in a consensual relationship. The Court noted that the complainant was an educated adult and fully aware that the parties were not married at the time they entered into the relationship.

The Court emphasized that human relationships are dynamic and subject to change over time. A consensual relationship, by itself, does not give rise to criminal liability under Section 376 IPC unless the statutory ingredients of the offence are clearly established. The Court held that merely because a relationship does not culminate in marriage due to incompatibility or temperamental differences, it cannot be forcibly converted into a lifelong relationship through the instrumentality of criminal law.

The Court carefully examined the FIR and found no allegations of force, coercion, or deceit at the inception of the relationship. It observed that there was nothing on record to suggest that the promise to marry, allegedly made by the petitioner, was false from the very beginning. On the contrary, the performance of a roka ceremony indicated a genuine intention to marry, which later could not be fulfilled due to intervening circumstances.

Justice Alok Jain observed that the FIR itself suggested that the alleged promise to marry failed due to irreconcilable differences between the parties and that the criminal proceedings were initiated only after the relationship had broken down. The Court held that such use of criminal law amounted to pressurising the petitioner and was an abuse of the process of law.

While acknowledging the emotional distress that may accompany the breakdown of a relationship, the Court clarified that criminal law cannot be invoked to remedy every personal grievance. The High Court reiterated that a failed consensual relationship, without more, does not constitute rape, and that courts must guard against the misuse of serious penal provisions in purely private disputes.

Accordingly, the Court allowed the petition and quashed the FIR along with all subsequent proceedings arising therefrom.