preloader image

Loading...

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

Supreme Court Seeks Election Commission’s Response to 48 Questions on SIR, Unanimous Decisions and Electoral Roll Revisions

Supreme Court Seeks Election Commission’s Response to 48 Questions on SIR, Unanimous Decisions and Electoral Roll Revisions

Introduction:

The Supreme Court on November 17 sought a response from the Election Commission of India (ECI) to an application filed by Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi and several other INDIA Bloc leaders seeking permission to serve 48 interrogatories on the Election Commission concerning its decision-making process and the implementation of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. The application seeks detailed explanations regarding the Commission’s claims that important decisions relating to the SIR were taken unanimously by all three Election Commissioners, as well as information concerning voter deletions, electoral roll modifications, the functioning of the ECINET platform and the introduction of additional declaration requirements in Form 6.

A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana heard the matter. After considering the preliminary submissions, the Court directed the Election Commission to file its objections to the application and scheduled the matter for further hearing on December 9. The Bench indicated that it would hear the petitioners on their request to administer interrogatories before passing an appropriate order.

The application has been filed through Advocate-on-Record Prasanna S. and forms part of the broader legal challenge questioning the Election Commission’s functioning during the Special Intensive Revision exercise. Apart from Rahul Gandhi and Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge, several prominent opposition leaders are among the petitioners. These include Saugata Roy of the Trinamool Congress, Akhilesh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party, Tejashwi Prasad Yadav of the Rashtriya Janata Dal, Sanjay Raut of Shiv Sena (UBT), M.A. Baby of the CPI(M), D. Raja of the CPI, Mahua Majhi of the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, Supriya Sule of the NCP (Sharad Pawar faction), and E.T. Mohammed Basheer of the Indian Union Muslim League. VCK President Thol. Thirumavalavan and National Conference MP Sajjad Ahmad Kichloo subsequently joined the proceedings.

The controversy primarily concerns the Election Commission’s decision to conduct the SIR and the manner in which the decisions associated with the exercise were taken. The petitioners have questioned whether the Commission acted collectively and unanimously, as subsequently asserted in its counter-affidavit, or whether certain decisions were taken without adequate deliberation or recorded approval from all its members.

The proceedings gained significance after the Supreme Court issued notice on October 15 on the petition filed by Gandhi and other opposition leaders challenging aspects of the Election Commission’s functioning during the SIR. The petitioners sought judicial scrutiny of the Commission’s decision-making process, particularly concerning the introduction and implementation of the revision exercise across the country.

On October 26, the Election Commission filed its counter-affidavit defending its actions. It maintained that the three orders concerning the SIR, dated June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026, had been approved unanimously by all three members of the Commission. It also rejected allegations that the Chief Election Commissioner had taken unilateral decisions concerning the exercise. The Commission further maintained that the additional declaration required during the revision exercise did not amount to an amendment of the statutory framework.

The petitioners, however, contend that these assertions are not accompanied by sufficient disclosure of the underlying official records. They argue that the counter-affidavit refers to unanimous decisions and approvals without identifying the relevant dates, file numbers, meeting records, electronic communications or other documents demonstrating how the decisions were actually taken.

Against this background, the application seeking permission to serve 48 interrogatories is intended to obtain specific information from the Election Commission and its officials. The questions extend beyond the approval of the counter-affidavit and examine the administrative process through which electoral roll revisions were implemented, the recording of objections by Election Commissioners, the handling of Form 6 applications, and the mechanisms available for restoring deleted electoral entries.

The matter raises important questions concerning transparency and accountability in the functioning of a constitutional authority, particularly one entrusted with the responsibility of conducting free and fair elections. It also brings into focus the extent to which parties challenging administrative decisions can seek disclosure of internal records and explanations through interrogatories during pending constitutional proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties:

Appearing for Rahul Gandhi and the other petitioners, Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal informed the Supreme Court that an application seeking permission to serve 48 interrogatories had been filed on the previous day. He submitted that the Election Commission’s counter-affidavit dated October 26 contained several significant assertions concerning unanimous decisions of the Commission, but did not disclose the records necessary to verify those claims.

According to Sibal, the Election Commission had repeatedly maintained that the three SIR orders were approved unanimously by its members. However, the counter-affidavit did not specify when such approvals were granted, whether they were recorded during formal meetings, whether the files were circulated individually or whether approval was conveyed through electronic communication.

The petitioners therefore sought permission to put specific questions to the Election Commission and its officials so that the factual basis of these assertions could be established through official records. Sibal’s submission was that the application was necessary because the Commission’s statements before the Court relied on a decision-making process that had not been adequately explained.

One of the principal questions concerns the counter-affidavit filed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu. The petitioners have sought to ascertain whether the affidavit was actually approved by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and the two Election Commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.

They have further sought clarification regarding the manner in which such approval was obtained. Specifically, they want to know whether the affidavit was approved during a meeting, through circulation of a file or by electronic communication. They have also sought the dates of approval, relevant official records and details of whether any member proposed modifications, expressed reservations or objected to the contents before the affidavit was filed.

The petitioners have also questioned the broader claim that decisions concerning the SIR were taken unanimously. They seek information regarding the number of occasions between February 19, 2025 and October 26, 2026 on which any Election Commissioner recorded a written objection, dissent or reservation concerning decisions relating to the SIR, ECINET, Form 6 and the filing of appeals.

They have asked the Commission to disclose whether the relevant decisions were taken unanimously or through majority approval and whether any disagreement was formally recorded in the official files.

Another significant aspect of the application concerns the three SIR orders dated June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026. The petitioners seek the corresponding file numbers, dates of approval and details of the decision-making process behind each order. They also want to know whether the decisions were taken during meetings or through file circulation or electronic communication and when each member formally signified approval.

Particular attention has been drawn to the June 24, 2025 order, which stated that the Commission had decided to commence the SIR exercise throughout the country. The petitioners have questioned the existence and documentation of such a nationwide decision by referring to an apparent inconsistency between the Commission’s counter-affidavit and an order passed by its First Appellate Authority under the Right to Information Act.

According to the application, the First Appellate Authority had reportedly stated that the Commission had not taken a decision to initiate a nationwide SIR in 2025. The petitioners have therefore sought clarification regarding the actual decision referred to in the June 24 order. They have also asked whether the relevant decision file existed when the Central Public Information Officer stated on August 27, 2025 that information concerning such a decision was unavailable.

The application further examines the introduction of an additional declaration on the online Form 6 application page. Form 6 is the prescribed application form used for the inclusion of a person’s name in the electoral roll. The petitioners want to know who introduced the additional declaration, when it was incorporated, whether the decision received approval from the Election Commission and whether any member of the Commission objected to its introduction.

They have also sought information concerning the number of Form 6 applications that were submitted, rejected, kept pending or left unprocessed because of the additional declaration or mapping-related requirements. In addition, they seek state-wise and Union Territory-wise information about electors whose names were excluded from draft or final electoral rolls, together with the recorded reasons for such exclusion.

These reasons include death, shifting of residence, absence, duplication and ineligibility. The petitioners have also sought information regarding objections filed through Form 7, including the number of objections submitted by individual applicants and Booth Level Agents, instances involving objections against false or non-existent persons, and the action taken in cases attracting Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950.

Another category of interrogatories relates to changes made to electoral rolls through technological and administrative processes. The petitioners have asked whether any electoral entry was added, deleted or modified without an order passed by the concerned Electoral Registration Officer. They have specifically sought details of any bulk, system-level, de-duplication or data-migration operations through which changes may have been carried out.

The application also raises questions about the functioning of ECINET, the Election Commission’s digital platform. The petitioners seek to know whether the platform provided Electoral Registration Officers with the facility to restore an electoral entry after it had been omitted or deleted during the SIR conducted pursuant to the orders dated October 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026.

If the restoration facility was unavailable at any stage, the Commission has been asked to disclose the period during which it remained unavailable and the date on which the facility was introduced.

The petitioners have additionally sought information regarding a proposal reportedly made by Election Commissioner Vivek Joshi concerning an audit of persons who had access to and the ability to modify the electoral roll database. They want to know whether the proposal was placed before the Commission, the date on which it was considered, the relevant file number and the decision taken.

The application also seeks details of appeals filed before Appellate Tribunals in West Bengal, either by the Election Commission or in the name of its officers, challenging orders passed by judicial officers directing the inclusion of names in electoral rolls.

On the other side, Senior Advocate Harish Salve, appearing for the Election Commission of India, informed the Bench that the Commission had serious reservations about the application seeking permission to serve the interrogatories. Although the precise grounds of objection were not elaborated upon in the submissions recorded during the hearing, the Commission indicated that it intended to oppose the request.

The Election Commission’s broader position, as reflected in its October 26 counter-affidavit, is that the decisions concerning the SIR were unanimously approved by all three members. It has denied the allegation that the Chief Election Commissioner acted unilaterally and defended the additional declaration introduced during the revision exercise, maintaining that it did not constitute an amendment to the statutory provisions.

Thus, the opposing positions centre on whether the petitioners should be permitted to obtain extensive internal information through interrogatories and whether the Election Commission’s assertions concerning unanimous decision-making require further disclosure of the underlying administrative records.

Court’s Judgment:

The Supreme Court did not decide the merits of the application seeking permission to serve the 48 interrogatories on November 17. Instead, after hearing the preliminary submissions, the Bench directed the Election Commission of India to file its objections to the application and listed the matter for further hearing on December 9.

The Bench made it clear that it would first hear the petitioners on their request to administer interrogatories and thereafter pass appropriate orders. Consequently, the Court has not yet permitted the petitioners to serve the questions, nor has it directed the Election Commission to answer all 48 interrogatories at this stage.

The direction to file objections is significant because it allows the Election Commission to formally explain why it opposes the proposed interrogatories before the Court determines whether such a procedure should be permitted in the pending proceedings.

The application raises an important procedural question concerning the use of interrogatories in proceedings before the Supreme Court. Interrogatories are written questions served upon an opposing party, requiring answers on oath, subject to the applicable procedural rules and the court’s permission. Their purpose is generally to clarify disputed factual matters, obtain relevant admissions and narrow the issues requiring adjudication.

Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, deals with discovery and inspection, including interrogatories in civil proceedings. Under the framework governing interrogatories, courts exercise control over the questions permitted to be served and may disallow questions that are irrelevant, unnecessary, oppressive or otherwise inappropriate. The underlying objective is to ensure that the procedure assists the fair and efficient determination of the dispute rather than becoming an instrument for unnecessary or excessive disclosure.

The proceedings before the Supreme Court also involve the Court’s powers under Article 32 of the Constitution, to the extent that the underlying challenge invokes the enforcement of constitutional rights, as well as its jurisdiction under Article 136 in matters arising from orders of other courts, where applicable. The Supreme Court’s procedural powers are also governed by the Supreme Court Rules, 2013, and the applicable provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure and other relevant laws.

The petitioners’ request is significant because the questions seek information concerning internal administrative decisions of a constitutional authority. The central issue is whether such information is sufficiently connected with the issues already raised in the pending SIR challenge to justify the use of interrogatories.

The petitioners essentially seek to verify the Election Commission’s claim that the three SIR orders were unanimously approved. If the Commission relies on collective approval as an important justification for its decisions, the petitioners contend that the underlying records demonstrating such approval should be identifiable and capable of scrutiny.

The proposed questions concerning the approval of the counter-affidavit are similarly directed towards establishing whether the statement that it was approved unanimously reflects a documented institutional decision. The distinction between an affidavit being filed by an authorised official and being approved through a unanimous decision of all three members may be relevant to the factual controversy raised by the petitioners.

However, the Court will have to consider whether each proposed question is necessary for deciding the pending dispute. Not every internal administrative communication or disagreement necessarily becomes relevant merely because it concerns the functioning of a public authority. The questions must have a sufficient connection with the issues before the Court and must be framed in a manner that assists judicial determination.

The application also raises questions concerning the Election Commission’s constitutional status and responsibilities. Article 324 of the Constitution vests the superintendence, direction and control of elections in the Election Commission of India. This constitutional responsibility extends to the preparation and conduct of elections, subject to the applicable constitutional and statutory framework.

The Representation of the People Act, 1950, provides the statutory framework governing the preparation and revision of electoral rolls. Section 21 deals with the preparation and revision of electoral rolls, while Section 22 provides for the correction of entries and Section 23 concerns the inclusion of names in electoral rolls. Section 31 deals with making false declarations in connection with electoral rolls.

These provisions are relevant to the questions raised in the application because the petitioners seek information about the legal and administrative basis for additions, deletions and modifications to electoral entries. Their questions concerning Form 6 and Form 7 are also directed towards understanding whether the statutory procedures were followed during the revision exercise.

Form 6 is used for applications seeking inclusion of names in electoral rolls, while Form 7 is used for objections to proposed inclusion or requests for deletion, as prescribed under the applicable electoral registration framework.

The petitioners’ request for information about applications rejected or kept pending because of additional declaration requirements raises a question about the relationship between administrative instructions and statutory requirements. The Commission’s position is that the additional declaration did not amount to an amendment of the law. The petitioners, however, seek to establish how the declaration was introduced, whether it was approved by the Commission and what practical consequences followed from its implementation.

The questions concerning the ECINET platform are equally important. The petitioners seek to determine whether the software provided Electoral Registration Officers with the ability to restore entries that had been omitted or deleted. This issue is relevant because technological systems used in electoral administration must operate consistently with the statutory responsibilities assigned to the officers concerned.

The application also seeks information about whether any bulk or system-level changes were made to electoral rolls without individual orders of the Electoral Registration Officers. The Court may therefore have to consider whether these questions are sufficiently relevant to the legality and transparency of the SIR process to justify disclosure through the proposed procedure.

Another important issue concerns the relationship between the Right to Information Act, 2005, and the information sought in the present proceedings. The petitioners have referred to an order passed by the First Appllate Authority of the Election Commission, reporte