Introduction:
In a significant ruling, the Karnataka High Court has held that the Kerala State or State Nursing Council cannot deny registration to nursing graduates from Karnataka or any other state solely because they did not complete their education in Kerala. The case arose when two Kerala natives, Daniya Joy and Neethu Baby, who had completed their BSc Nursing degrees in Karnataka, were denied registration by the Kerala Nurses and Midwives Council on the ground that their institution was not affiliated with the Indian Nursing Council (INC). The Kerala Council had insisted that the petitioners provide a certificate from the INC stating that their college was properly recognised, but this request was challenged by the petitioners because they had already completed their education and obtained their degrees from a recognised university in Karnataka.
Arguments:
The petitioners argued that the degree conferred upon them by Karnataka University should be valid throughout India, and they should not be barred from practising nursing in Kerala simply because they completed their studies in another state. They contended that such an arbitrary requirement for an INC certificate was discriminatory and against the principles of equality guaranteed under the Constitution of India, as well as the broader recognition of academic qualifications across the country.
The Kerala Nursing Council, on the other hand, defended its position by citing Section 21 of the Kerala Nurses and Midwives Act, 1953, which mandates that no person can practice nursing in Kerala without registering with the Kerala State Council. The Council further referred to Section 13 of the Indian Nursing Council Act, 1947, which requires a suitability certificate for institutions providing nursing education. The Kerala Council argued that it was within its rights to ask for additional documentation to ensure the qualifications were up to the national standard.
Judgement:
However, Justice Suraj Govindaraj, in his judgment, rejected the Kerala Council’s stance, noting that once a degree is conferred upon an individual by a recognised university, that degree is valid nationwide. The court emphasised that there was no legal basis for a state council to deny recognition of a degree obtained in another state, especially when the institution offering the course was recognised by the respective state nursing council. The judge pointed out that the Indian Nursing Council does not mandate that colleges must seek registration with it for providing nursing courses, nor does it require graduates to hold an INC certificate before applying for registration in another state.
The court also found that the Kerala Nurses and Midwives Council’s demand for an INC certificate was unreasonable, as there is no provision under the Indian Nursing Council Act requiring such a certificate for graduates. The judgment also highlighted the constitutional principle that all Indian citizens are entitled to move freely within the country and to practice their profession in any state without being subjected to arbitrary restrictions based on the state in which they were educated. The court noted that the petitioners, having studied in Karnataka, should not be discriminated against when seeking to practice in their home state of Kerala.
In terms of legal principles, the court referred to Section 21 of the Kerala Nurses and Midwives Act and Section 13 of the Indian Nursing Council Act, analysing their application to the case at hand. The court clarified that while Section 13 deals with the suitability of nursing colleges, it does not give the Kerala Nursing Council the authority to demand an INC certificate from graduates who have obtained their degrees from colleges already recognised by state nursing councils. The court further observed that the requirement for a suitability certificate only applies in cases where a complaint has been lodged regarding the institution, not as a blanket requirement for registration.
The ruling marks a victory for the petitioners, as the court directed the Kerala Nurses and Midwives Council to register them and any other similarly situated nursing graduates. This ruling effectively negates the need for additional state-specific registration procedures for graduates from other states, recognising the right of individuals to practice their profession across the country based on the qualifications they have obtained, regardless of the state where the degree was awarded.
In his conclusion, Justice Govindaraj observed that India, as a unified nation, guarantees its citizens the fundamental right to practice any profession anywhere in the country. He emphasised that no law or state authority could prevent an individual from using their qualifications to earn a livelihood in any part of the country, thereby rejecting narrow, parochial views that restricted professional mobility.
The case sets an important precedent for inter-state recognition of professional qualifications in India, particularly in fields such as nursing, where the demand for professionals is high. It highlights the need for a unified approach to professional registration and recognition, ensuring that graduates are not subjected to unnecessary barriers based on regional considerations.