Introduction:

The Karnataka High Court has rejected a petition filed by Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, Congress’ State in-charge Randeep Singh Surjewala, and legislators Ramalinga Reddy and MB Patil. The petition sought to quash a criminal case registered against them for an alleged illegal march towards the residence of then Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai. The court’s decision directs Siddaramaiah to appear before the Special Court on March 6 and imposes a cost of Rs. 10,000 on each petitioner for involving a police officer personally.

Arguments of Both Sides:

The accused, including Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, contended that the criminal case against them was politically motivated and lacked merit. They argued that the police officer was incorrectly made a party respondent in her personal capacity. The prosecution emphasized that the march, demanding the resignation of then Minister KS Eshwarappa, violated laws and created chaos on public roads. The defense asserted that the police action reeked of malice, and the proceedings were initiated to humiliate them.

Court’s Judgment:

Justice Krishna S Dixit dismissed the petition, citing legal considerations and referring to judgments, including an American court decision. The court set specific dates for each petitioner to appear before the Special Court. Siddaramaiah was directed to appear on March 6, Surjewala on March 7, MB Patil on March 11, and Ramalinga Reddy on March 15. The court emphasized adherence to the law and rejected the petitioners’ request for a stay on the judgment. It underlined the equality of individuals before the law and the impact of public protests on city life.