preloader image

Loading...

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

Calcutta High Court Halts Further Demolition of Residential House Over Doubts About Service of Hearing Notices on Incarcerated Owner

Calcutta High Court Halts Further Demolition of Residential House Over Doubts About Service of Hearing Notices on Incarcerated Owner

Introduction:

The Calcutta High Court has restrained the authorities from carrying out further demolition of a residential property belonging to Jahangir Khan after finding that serious questions remained unanswered regarding the service of hearing notices before the demolition proceedings were initiated. The Court observed that although the State claimed to have issued and affixed several notices at the property, Khan was admittedly in judicial custody at the relevant time, and no attempt appeared to have been made to serve the notices upon him at the correctional home.

Justice Suvra Ghosh directed the State authorities to produce the videographic recording of the alleged affixation of notices at Khan’s residence to establish whether the prescribed procedure had actually been followed. Pending further consideration, the Court restrained the respondents from undertaking any additional demolition work and directed that the matter be listed on November 16, 2026, at 2 PM.

The proceedings arose from a dispute concerning the demolition of Jahangir Khan’s residential house under the provisions of the West Bengal Panchayat Act, 1973. The petitioner questioned the legality of the demolition proceedings, primarily on the ground that he had not received an effective opportunity of hearing before the authorities proceeded against his property.

According to the petitioner’s case, Khan had been in custody since June 8, 2026. His wife was also subsequently taken into custody, while their son allegedly became unable to reside at the property because the house had been vandalised and threats had been extended to his life and property. As a result, the residential premises were allegedly left vacant and damaged.

The petitioner further claimed that important documents kept inside the house, including the sanctioned building plan, had been stolen. This circumstance assumed significance because the State subsequently relied upon the absence of an approved building plan while defending the demolition proceedings.

The dispute also involved the manner in which hearing notices were allegedly served. The State maintained that notices had been issued by the Hearing Officer and the Executive Officer and affixed at a conspicuous location on the property. However, Khan disputed the authenticity and adequacy of this alleged service, pointing out that he was incarcerated and that the authorities had not attempted to communicate the notices to him through the correctional home.

The petitioner also questioned the evidentiary value of the photographs and reports produced by the authorities. According to him, the photographs did not establish that the premises shown actually belonged to him, while the report concerning the alleged affixation of notices did not contain the signature of any local witness.

The State, on the other hand, maintained that the petitioner had been provided several opportunities to participate in the proceedings but had failed to appear before the concerned authorities. It also relied upon the finding of the Zilla Parishad that no sanctioned building plan had been issued in Khan’s favour for the construction in question.

The controversy therefore raised important questions concerning procedural fairness in demolition proceedings, the validity of service of statutory notices, the obligation of public authorities to provide an effective opportunity of hearing and the limits of administrative action affecting residential property.

Section 160A(6) of the West Bengal Panchayat Act, 1973, was specifically referred to in the proceedings in connection with the issuance of hearing notices. The Court was required to examine whether the authorities had complied with the applicable procedural requirements before proceeding with the demolition.

At the present stage, however, the High Court did not finally determine whether the construction was authorised or whether the demolition order was legally sustainable. Instead, it focused on the preliminary but significant question of whether the petitioner had been afforded a genuine opportunity to participate in the proceedings.

By directing the State to produce the videographic evidence of the alleged service process and temporarily restraining further demolition, the Court sought to ensure that the legality of the administrative action would be examined before additional damage was caused to the disputed residential property.

Arguments of the Parties:

The petitioner, Jahangir Khan, challenged the demolition proceedings on the ground that the authorities had proceeded against his residential property without ensuring that the statutory hearing notices were effectively served upon him.

His principal contention was that he had been in custody since June 8, 2026, and was therefore not in a position to receive or respond to notices allegedly affixed at his residence. Despite the authorities being required to provide him an opportunity of hearing, no attempt had been made to serve the relevant notices at the correctional home where he was confined.

The petitioner argued that the alleged affixation of notices at the residential premises could not automatically be treated as sufficient service, particularly when the authorities were dealing with a person who was already in custody. According to him, the State should have taken appropriate steps to communicate the proceedings to him at the place of his detention so that he could respond to the allegations and defend his property.

It was further submitted that the condition of the house made it difficult to accept the State’s claim that the notices had been effectively brought to the attention of the family. Khan’s counsel informed the Court that his wife had also subsequently been taken into custody, leaving their son in a vulnerable position.

The son was allegedly unable to continue residing in the house because it had been vandalised and threats had been made against his life and property. Consequently, the premises were lying vacant and damaged.

The petitioner also explained that his son had mentioned the disputed house as his residential address in an affidavit filed along with the writ petition. However, the affidavit did not indicate that the son was actually residing there at the time of the proceedings, as he had allegedly shifted elsewhere due to the circumstances surrounding the property.

Another important submission concerned the manner in which the petitioner allegedly came to know about the demolition. It was contended that Khan learnt about the demolition only through social media after the demolition work had already commenced. According to the petitioner, this demonstrated that he had not received prior effective communication regarding the proceedings or the proposed action against his house.

The petitioner also disputed the State’s assertion that notices had been affixed at a conspicuous place at the property. His counsel questioned whether the photographs produced by the State were sufficient to establish that the premises depicted in them actually belonged to Khan.

Further, attention was drawn to the report prepared by the person who allegedly carried out the affixation of notices. The petitioner pointed out that the report did not bear the signature of any local witness who could independently confirm that the notices had actually been affixed at the relevant premises.

Although the person concerned claimed to have consulted local residents, those residents were allegedly unable to provide any information about Khan or his family. The petitioner therefore questioned the reliability of the report and argued that the State had failed to establish proper service through independent and verifiable evidence.

The petitioner also disputed the reliance placed upon the absence of a sanctioned building plan. It was submitted that the relevant building documents, including the sanctioned plan, had been kept inside the house but were subsequently stolen after the premises were vandalised. This circumstance was relevant to the petitioner’s challenge to the State’s position concerning the legality of the construction.

On the other hand, the Advocate General, appearing for the State, opposed the petition and defended the proceedings undertaken by the authorities.

The State submitted that the Hearing Officer had issued several hearing notices to Khan before taking up the matter for consideration. According to the Advocate General, the authorities had followed the prescribed procedure and had taken steps to communicate the proceedings to the petitioner.

It was specifically contended that the notices had been affixed to a wall of Khan’s residential premises at a conspicuous location. The State further asserted that the process of affixation had been videographed, thereby creating a record of the steps taken by the authorities to serve the notices.

The Advocate General argued that Khan had failed to appear before either the Hearing Officer or the Executive Officer despite having been granted several opportunities. According to the State, the authorities had not proceeded against the petitioner without notice but had taken the necessary steps to enable him to participate in the proceedings.

The State further submitted that the demolition order had been passed after the Zilla Parishad confirmed that no sanctioned building plan had been issued in Khan’s favour for the construction in question.

It was therefore argued that the demolition proceedings were supported by the findings of the competent authorities and that the petitioner could not challenge the action merely by claiming that he had not received the notices.

The Advocate General also raised a procedural objection regarding the scope of the challenge. It was submitted that Khan had specifically challenged the order passed by the Executive Officer but had not independently questioned the hearing conducted by the Hearing Officer.

According to the State, this distinction was relevant because the petitioner could not selectively challenge the final administrative decision while leaving the earlier proceedings and findings of the Hearing Officer undisputed.

The State accordingly maintained that the demolition action had been undertaken after following the prescribed process and that there was no justification for restraining the authorities from proceeding further.

Court’s Judgment:

After considering the submissions advanced by both sides, Justice Suvra Ghosh found that the question of proper service of hearing notices required closer examination before the authorities could be permitted to continue with the demolition of Khan’s residential property.

The Court initially took note of the affidavit filed by Khan’s son along with the writ petition. In the affidavit, the son had affirmed that he was a resident of the disputed house. However, the Court also noticed that the affidavit did not disclose the place where he was presently residing.

This circumstance was considered alongside the petitioner’s submission that the family members had been unable to continue residing at the property because of vandalism and threats. The Court therefore considered it necessary to examine the surrounding circumstances before accepting the State’s assertion that notices had been effectively served at the premises.

The Bench also noted that several notices appeared to have been issued under Section 160A(6) of the West Bengal Panchayat Act, 1973, by both the Hearing Officer and the Executive Officer.

However, the existence of notices on the official record was not, by itself, sufficient to resolve the dispute. The crucial question was whether the authorities had actually taken legally adequate steps to bring those notices to the petitioner’s attention and provide him with a meaningful opportunity to participate in the proceedings.

In this regard, the Court attached considerable importance to the admitted fact that Khan was in custody during the relevant period.

The petitioner had been confined in a correctional home since June 8, 2026. Despite this fact, the authorities had apparently not attempted to serve the hearing notices upon him at the correctional home.

The State sought to explain this circumstance by submitting that the authorities were unaware of Khan’s incarceration. However, the Court was not prepared to treat this explanation as sufficient to conclude the issue at the present stage.

Justice Ghosh observed:

“Though the authority submits that the authority was ignorant about the said fact, the issue needs to be dealt with at a later stage.”

This observation indicates that the Court considered the petitioner’s incarceration a relevant circumstance while examining the adequacy of the notice process. When a person is in judicial custody, the question of whether notices affixed at his residence can provide an effective opportunity of hearing assumes particular importance.

The purpose of a hearing notice is not merely to complete a procedural formality. It is intended to communicate the proposed action to the affected person and provide a reasonable opportunity to respond before an adverse decision is taken.

Where the affected individual is unable to access his residence because he is incarcerated, the authority may be required to explain the steps taken to ensure that the proceedings are communicated to him through an appropriate channel, in accordance with the applicable law.

The Court did not, at this preliminary stage, finally determine whether service by affixation was legally invalid in the circumstances. Instead, it required the State to establish the factual basis of its claim that the notices had been properly affixed.

Another significant factor considered by the Court was the absence of independent local witnesses in the report concerning the alleged service of notices.

The Bench noted that the report prepared by the person who allegedly affixed the notices did not bear the signature of any local witness. Although the person concerned claimed to have consulted residents of the locality, those individuals were reportedly unable to provide any information regarding Khan or his family.

This aspect raised questions about the reliability and evidentiary value of the report produced by the State.

The Court’s concern was not confined to the formal existence of a report. It also extended to whether the circumstances recorded in that report could be independently verified and whether the State had sufficient material to establish that the notices had actually been affixed at the petitioner’s residential premises.

The absence of local witnesses did not, by itself, result in a final finding that the notices had not been served. Nevertheless, it was a relevant circumstance that required examination, particularly when the petitioner had specifically disputed the photographs and the identity of the premises shown in them.

The Court therefore considered it necessary to examine the videographic evidence relied upon by the State.

The Advocate General had specifically submitted that the process of affixation had been videographed. Since the State was relying upon this recording to establish compliance with the notice procedure, the Court directed it to produce the videograph before the next hearing.

This direction was significant because it required the authorities to substantiate their claim through contemporaneous visual evidence rather than relying exclusively upon their own written report.

The recording could assist the Court in determining whether the notices were actually affixed at the disputed property, the circumstances in which the alleged service was carried out and whether the process corresponded with the description contained in the official report.

The Bench also considered the broader requirement of procedural fairness in administrative proceedings affecting property rights.

The right to a fair hearing is an essential component of the principles of natural justice. Whenever an authority proposes to take action adversely affecting an individual’s rights or interests, the person concerned must ordinarily be afforded a reasonable opportunity to present his case, subject to the governing statutory framework.

The principles of natural justice are intended to ensure that administrative decisions are not taken arbitrarily or without considering the affected person’s explanation.

The requirement of notice is particularly important in proceedings involving demolition because the consequences may be irreversible. Once a residential structure is demolished, the affected person may suffer substantial and permanent prejudice even if the administrative action is subsequently found to be legally defective.

The principles underlying the Supreme Court’s decisions in State of Orissa v. Dr. (Miss) Binapani Dei and Canara Bank v. Debasis Das recognise the importance of fair procedure and a meaningful opportunity of hearing before adverse administrative or quasi-judicial action is taken.

The present proceedings, however, did not result in a final ruling on the legality of the demolition order or the precise requirements governing service under Section 160A(6) of the West Bengal Panchayat Act. The High Court’s intervention was limited to ensuring that the State established whether the petitioner had been afforded the required opportunity before further demolition was permitted.

The Court also took note of the fact that the petitioner had challenged the Executive Officer’s order, while the State argued that the proceedings before the Hearing Officer had not independently been questioned.

However, the existence of this procedural objection did not persuade the Court to permit further demolition without first examining the disputed question of service.

The central concern remained whether the authorities had complied with the statutory procedure and whether the petitioner had been given a genuine opportunity to contest the proposed action.

The Bench therefore concluded that the State would have to substantiate the service of hearing notices issued by both the Hearing Officer and the Executive Officer before any further demolition of the residential house could be permitted.

Considering the competing submissions and the disputed circumstances surrounding service, the Court held that the matter required a more detailed hearing.

Accordingly, Justice Suvra Ghosh directed the State to produce the videographic recording of the alleged affixation of notices at Khan’s residence. The matter was directed to be listed again on November 16, 2026, at 2 PM, for further consideration.

In the meantime, the respondents were restrained from carrying out any further demolition of Jahangir Khan’s residential house.

The interim protection was granted without finally deciding the merits of the dispute. The Court did not declare the construction authorised, nor did it set aside the demolition order at this stage. Instead, it ensured that no additional demolition would take place until the authorities established whether the prescribed notice procedure had been followed.

The order is significant because it highlights that procedural compliance cannot be reduced to the mere issuance or physical affixation of notices when the affected person disputes having received an effective opportunity of hearing. Administrative authorities must be able to demonstrate that the statutory process was followed, particularly when their actions may result in the demolition of a residential property.

The judgment also underscores the importance of examining the circumstances of an affected person’s custody while assessing the adequacy of service. Where an individual is incarcerated, authorities must address whether reasonable steps were taken to communicate the proceedins to him rather than relying solely upon the alleged affixation of notices