Introduction:
The Calcutta High Court has held that Anganwadi centres qualify as recognised educational institutions for the purpose of Rule 8 of the West Bengal Excise (New Sites and Grant of Licence) Rules, 2003. Consequently, a foreign liquor shop cannot be shifted to a proposed location situated within 1,000 feet of an Anganwadi centre. The Court observed that these centres provide pre-school and elementary education to young children and are recognised under the statutory framework governing children’s education. Their educational character cannot be disregarded merely because they operate under the Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) Scheme rather than the conventional School Education Department.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Shampa Sarkar and Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee dismissed an intra-court appeal filed by a liquor shop owner challenging the refusal of the excise authorities to permit relocation of his shop to his own land. The Bench upheld the decision of the Single Judge, who had rejected the appellant’s challenge to the refusal of permission on the ground that the proposed site was situated within the prohibited distance from an Anganwadi centre.
The appeal, MAT 2297 of 2025, arose from an order dated October 5, 2023, passed in WPA 22977 of 2022. The dispute concerned the interpretation of Rule 8(1) of the 2003 Excise Rules, which regulates the location of liquor shops in relation to specified institutions, including educational establishments. The principal question was whether an Anganwadi centre could be treated as a recognised educational institution for applying the restriction.
The appellant had been operating a foreign liquor shop under the name and style of ‘Tinar More CS Shop’ from rented premises at Mouza Tinar, within Sarai Tinar Gram Panchayat in Hooghly district. He subsequently sought permission from the competent excise authority to shift the shop to land owned by him. However, the request was rejected because the proposed location was found to be within 1,000 feet of an Anganwadi centre.
Aggrieved by the refusal, the shop owner approached the High Court through a writ petition. He contended that an Anganwadi centre could not be equated with an educational institution recognised by the State or Central Government within the meaning of Rule 8(1). According to him, such centres were primarily established to provide childcare and nutritional services and were not governed by the statutory framework applicable to conventional schools.
The Single Judge rejected this contention, relying upon the provisions of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Rules, 2012, and dismissed the writ petition. The appellant thereafter preferred an appeal before the Division Bench.
The State defended the refusal of permission, maintaining that Anganwadi centres were covered by the expression ‘educational institution’ under the 2003 Excise Rules. It also relied upon a notification dated January 20, 2012, issued by the West Bengal Excise Department, which clarified that Anganwadi centres could not be excluded from the scope of educational institutions for the purpose of the relevant restriction.
The Division Bench examined the statutory framework governing Anganwadi centres, including the National Food Security Act, 2013, the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, and the West Bengal Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Rules, 2012. On considering these provisions, the Court concluded that Anganwadi centres perform an educational function recognised by law and therefore fall within the category of schools for implementing Rule 8 of the 2003 Excise Rules.
The Bench found no illegality or perversity in the Single Judge’s decision and dismissed the appeal. However, it clarified that the appellant would remain free to approach the competent authority if he maintained that the proposed site was actually situated beyond 1,000 feet from the Anganwadi centre. In that event, the authority would be required to examine the matter in accordance with law after providing him an opportunity of being heard.
Before examining the merits of the appeal, the Division Bench also considered the appellant’s application seeking condonation of delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963. The Court accepted the explanation for the delay, subject to payment of costs of ₹5,000 to the West Bengal State Legal Services Authority, to be transmitted to the funds of the High Court’s Juvenile Justice Committee.
Arguments of the Parties:
The appellant challenged the refusal of the excise authorities to permit the relocation of his foreign liquor shop, primarily questioning the legal status of an Anganwadi centre under Rule 8(1) of the West Bengal Excise (New Sites and Grant of Licence) Rules, 2003.
Advocate Bhattacharya, appearing for the appellant, submitted that an Anganwadi centre could not be treated at par with an educational institution recognised by either the State Government or the Central Government. According to the appellant, the restriction under Rule 8(1) was intended to protect conventional educational institutions and should not automatically extend to every establishment that provided some form of childcare or pre-school activity.
The appellant argued that Anganwadi centres were not governed by the statutory framework administered by the School Education Department. Their establishment and functioning were connected with the ICDS Scheme, which primarily focuses on child development and welfare. Therefore, merely because children received certain educational services at these centres, they could not be treated as recognised schools for the purpose of imposing restrictions on the location of liquor shops.
The appellant sought to distinguish between an institution that provides educational services and one that is formally recognised as an educational institution under the applicable government framework. His contention was that the relevant excise restriction could not be extended to Anganwadi centres without establishing that they satisfied the requirement of recognition contemplated under Rule 8(1).
He also raised a factual objection concerning the distance between the proposed liquor shop and the Anganwadi centre. It was submitted that the proposed site was situated more than 1,000 feet away from the centre. According to the appellant, the Single Judge had failed to properly consider this aspect while dismissing the writ petition.
On this basis, the appellant sought interference with the order dated October 5, 2023, and requested that the refusal of permission to shift the liquor shop be set aside.
Opposing the appeal, Additional Government Pleader Saha Dutta submitted that the appellant’s interpretation of Rule 8(1) was incorrect. She argued that Anganwadi centres were covered by the expression ‘educational institution’ and could not be excluded from the restriction merely because their institutional structure differed from that of conventional schools.
The State relied upon the notification dated January 20, 2012, issued by the West Bengal Excise Department. According to the State, the notification clarified that Anganwadi centres were included within the meaning of educational institutions for the purpose of the relevant excise provision.
The State further relied upon the statutory recognition given to pre-school and elementary education under the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, and the rules framed by the State Government. It maintained that Anganwadi centres provide educational services to children, particularly those in the three-to-six-year age group, and therefore perform a function that falls within the protective purpose of the restriction.
The State’s position was that the appellant could not seek to exclude Anganwadi centres merely because they were established under the ICDS Scheme. Their educational role and recognition under the applicable legal framework were sufficient to bring them within the scope of Rule 8(1).
The State accordingly supported the Single Judge’s conclusion and argued that the refusal to permit relocation was legally justified.
The parties’ submissions thus required the Division Bench to determine whether the expression ‘educational institution’ under the 2003 Excise Rules should be confined to conventional schools formally administered by the School Education Department or whether it also covered Anganwadi centres recognised under the statutory framework governing early childhood education.
Court’s Judgment:
The Calcutta High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the Single Judge’s decision, holding that Anganwadi centres fall within the category of recognised educational institutions for the purpose of Rule 8 of the West Bengal Excise (New Sites and Grant of Licence) Rules, 2003.
The Division Bench found no infirmity or perversity in the conclusion that a liquor shop could not be shifted to a proposed location falling within 1,000 feet of an Anganwadi centre. It rejected the appellant’s attempt to distinguish Anganwadi centres from other educational institutions merely on the basis of their administrative structure or the scheme under which they operate.
The Court began by examining the nature and functions of Anganwadi centres. It noted that these centres are established under the Integrated Child Development Services Scheme and provide a range of services aimed at the care and development of young children. Their role is not confined to nutrition and childcare; they also provide pre-school and elementary educational support to children, particularly those between three and six years of age.
The Bench considered this educational function relevant to the interpretation of Rule 8(1). The fact that an Anganwadi centre may not operate like a conventional school or fall under the administrative control of the School Education Department does not, by itself, deprive it of its legal recognition as an institution providing education to children.
In reaching this conclusion, the Court referred to Section 2(1) of the National Food Security Act, 2013. This provision defines an Anganwadi centre as a child care and development centre set up under the Central Government’s ICDS Scheme to provide services contemplated under the Act.
The statutory definition helped the Court understand the nature and institutional role of Anganwadi centres. They are not merely informal childcare facilities but establishments created within a recognised government scheme for the care, development and welfare of children. Their functions must therefore be understood in the context of the wider statutory framework governing early childhood development.
The Court also examined Section 11 of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009. This provision requires the appropriate Government to make necessary arrangements for providing free pre-school education to children above the age of three years until they complete six years.
The Bench considered this provision particularly relevant because Anganwadi centres provide pre-school educational services to children within this age group. Section 11 reflects the legislative recognition of the importance of early childhood education and places responsibility upon the Government to make appropriate arrangements for its provision.
The Court’s attention then turned to Rule 5(5)(iv) of the West Bengal Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Rules, 2012. This provision requires the register maintained by local authorities to include the name of the school, pre-school, Anganwadi centre or Alternative Innovative Education Centre where a child receives elementary education up to the age of six years.
The inclusion of Anganwadi centres alongside schools and pre-schools in the relevant provision was significant. It demonstrated that the State’s own rules recognise Anganwadi centres as establishments where children receive educational services. Their inclusion in the statutory framework cannot be disregarded merely because they do not possess the same institutional structure as conventional schools.
On a combined reading of these provisions, the Division Bench concluded that Anganwadi centres provide pre-school and elementary education to children and enjoy recognition under the 2009 Act and the rules framed under it.
The Bench observed that the legal recognition of these centres as educational institutions was not in doubt. It stated, “The fact that they are educational institutions, recognized by law is not in doubt.”
This finding directly addressed the appellant’s principal contention. The appellant had argued that an Anganwadi centre could not be treated as an educational institution recognised by the State or Central Government because it was not governed by the School Education Department. The Court rejected this narrow approach and focused instead on the statutory recognition and educational functions of the institution.
The Division Bench held that Anganwadi centres fall within the category of schools for the purpose of implementing Rule 8 of the 2003 Excise Rules. Consequently, the restriction concerning the location of liquor shops within 1,000 feet of an educational institution applies to such centres as well.
The significance of the ruling lies in its purposive interpretation of the expression ‘educational institution’. The Court did not confine the term to institutions following the conventional school model. Instead, it examined the legislative framework relating to early childhood education and considered whether the institution performed an educational role recognised by law.
The decision also reflects the importance of reading related statutory provisions together. The National Food Security Act identifies the institutional character of Anganwadi centres, while the Right to Education Act and the West Bengal Rules recognise the role of such centres in providing pre-school and elementary education. These provisions, when considered collectively, support their inclusion within the protective scope of the excise restriction.
The Court’s approach also recognises that the purpose of restrictions on the location of liquor shops near educational institutions is not necessarily limited to protecting children attending conventional schools. Children receiving pre-school education at Anganwadi centres are equally within the group of young learners whom such restrictions are intended to protect.
The Court therefore declined to accept an interpretation that would exclude Anganwadi centres merely because they function under the ICDS Scheme. Such an approach would overlook their educational role and the recognition extended to them under the applicable legal provisions.
The Division Bench also considered the appellant’s factual submission that the proposed shop was situated beyond the prohibited distance. While upholding the legal position that Anganwadi centres are covered by Rule 8, the Court made an important clarification concerning the measurement of distance.
It observed that its decision would not prevent the appellant from approaching the competent authority if he maintained that the proposed site was actually situated beyond 1,000 feet from the Anganwadi centre. In such a situation, the competent authority was directed to take appropriate steps in accordance with law after giving the appellant due notice.
This clarification is significant because the Court distinguished between the legal question concerning the status of an Anganwadi centre and the factual question concerning the actual distance of the proposed liquor shop from that centre. The legal position was settled by the judgment, but the appellant was not prevented from seeking a fresh consideration of the factual distance if he could substantiate his claim.
Thus, although the appeal was dismissed, the Court left open a limited opportunity for the appellant to establish before the competent authority that the proposed location did not fall within the 1,000-foot restriction. The authority would then have to examine the claim in accordance with law and after providing the appellant an opportunity of being heard.
Condonation of delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act
Before proceeding to examine the merits of the appeal, the Division Bench also considered the appellant’s application seeking condonation of delay in filing the intra-court appeal under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
The appellant explained that his wife, son and mother had suffered serious illnesses and had been hospitalised. He submitted that these circumstances had caused considerable mental stress and prevented him from properly following up with his advocate regarding the writ petition and the subsequent appeal.
The State opposed the application for condonation of delay. However, after considering the explanation furnished by the appellant, the Bench found that sufficient cause had been shown to justify condonation.
The Court therefore allowed the application, subject to payment of costs of ₹5,000 to the West Bengal State Legal Services Authority within three weeks. The amount was directed to be transmitted to the funds of the High Court’s Juvenile Justice Committee.
The Court thus accepted the explanation for the delay while imposing costs as a condition for granting the procedural relief. This enabled the appeal to be considered on its merits without treating the delay as an insurmountable obstacle.
Ultimately, the Division Bench found no ground to interfere with the Single Judge’s order dated October 5, 2023. It held that Anganwadi centres are recognised educational institutions for the purpose of Rule 8 of the 2003 Excise Rules and that a liquor shop cannot be shifted to a site situated within 1,000 feet of such a centre.
The intra-court appeal was dismissed as devoid of merit, without any further order as to costs.
The judgment is significant because it recognises the educational character of Anganwadi centres within the framework of laws governing child development and early education. It also clarifies that statutory restrictions intended to protect educational environments cannot be avoided simply because an institution operates under a government welfare scheme rather than the conventional school education system. By adopting a broader statutory understanding of educational institutions, the Calcutta High Court has reinforced the importance of protecting young children receiving pre-school education at Anganwadi centres.