Introduction:
The Madras High Court granted bail to Rangarajan Narasimhan, a temple activist, in connection with allegations of derogatory comments made against a woman on social media. Justice V. Lakshminarayanan presided over the matter, issuing interim bail on conditions, including the deletion of all offensive posts and a directive to refrain from making vituperative remarks against women on any platform. The court had earlier penalized Narasimhan in another case for similar conduct, underscoring the importance of maintaining decorum while representing traditional values like Sanatana Dharma.
Arguments of Both Sides:
Counsel for the petitioner, T.S. Vijayaraghavan, argued that the complaint and the subsequent charges lacked merit. He contended that Section 75 of the BNS 2023, invoked against Narasimhan, necessitated elements of sexual harassment, which were absent in the present case. Further, he asserted that Section 73 of the same Act was a bailable offence and that Narasimhan’s remarks were a simple transliteration of common Tamil phrases. He also pointed out that the Principal Sessions Court was closed for the Christmas holidays, making the High Court an appropriate forum for urgent relief under Section 483 of the BNSS.
The respondent, represented by Government Advocate K.M.D. Mugilan argued that Narasimhan’s derogatory remarks violated multiple statutory provisions, including Sections 75 and 79 of the BNS 2023, Section 4 of the Prohibition of Harassment of Women Act 2002, and Section 67 of the Information Technology Act 2000. It was submitted that such conduct on social media perpetuates harmful stereotypes and creates a hostile environment, justifying the charges and Narasimhan’s arrest.
Court’s Judgment:
The court examined the allegations and legal provisions carefully. Justice V. Lakshminarayanan noted that the petitioner’s remarks, while distasteful, did not fulfil the requirements to establish an offence under Section 75 of the BNS 2023, as the provision requires sexual harassment to constitute a punishable act. Similarly, the court found no grounds for invoking Section 4 of the Prohibition of Harassment of Women Act 2002 in this case. The remaining offences under Section 73 of the BNS and Section 67 of the IT Act were deemed bailable.
The court further addressed procedural objections raised by the Registry regarding the maintainability of the petition. It upheld the argument presented by Narasimhan’s counsel, who cited Section 483 of the BNSS, affirming concurrent jurisdiction of the High Court and Sessions Court for such cases. Considering the closure of the Principal Sessions Court due to holidays and the matter’s urgency concerning the petitioner’s right to liberty, the court exercised its jurisdiction to hear the bail application.
Justice Lakshminarayanan granted bail to Narasimhan under stringent conditions. The activist was ordered to delete all offensive comments immediately and refrain from making disparaging remarks against women in the future. The court emphasized the need for restraint and responsible use of social media platforms, particularly for individuals claiming to represent cultural or religious values. It reiterated the significance of setting a positive example in public discourse.
While granting bail, the court also referred to a prior case involving Narasimhan, where he had been ordered to undergo a two-week “social media detox” for similar inappropriate behaviour. The bench noted that such repeated offences highlighted the necessity for stricter adherence to ethical communication standards.
The court’s judgment reflects a balanced approach, protecting individual liberty while addressing societal concerns about derogatory and offensive language in public spaces. The matter also underscores the judiciary’s evolving role in tackling challenges arising from digital platforms and their misuse.