Introduction:

In the case between Setara Bibi and the State of NCT of Delhi & Others, the Delhi High Court addressed the tragic death of Sheikh Sahadat allegedly in police custody. Setara Bibi, Sahadat’s wife, sought justice through the registration of an FIR against the responsible police officials and the constitution of a Special Investigation Team (SIT) for an impartial inquiry. The court intervened to expedite the magisterial enquiry into Sahadat’s death, ensuring timely action and accountability.

Arguments:

Setara Bibi’s counsel, Senior Advocate Rebecca John, highlighted the state’s insensitivity towards Sahadat’s death and the alleged brutality he faced in custody. She emphasized the urgency of the matter, citing evidence of injuries documented by Sahadat’s family. On the other hand, the respondents’ counsel, led by Mr. Sanjeev Bhandari, contended for due process and procedural fairness, while acknowledging the seriousness of the allegations.

Court’s Judgment:

Justice Jyoti Singh of the Delhi High Court directed the expeditious conclusion of the magisterial enquiry within three months. The court emphasized the need for empathy, sensitivity, and seriousness in handling the inquiry and the application for FIR registration. It instructed the concerned authorities to expedite the forensic report and proceed with the matter diligently. This ruling reflects the court’s commitment to ensuring accountability and justice in cases of custodial deaths.