Introduction:
The Karnataka High Court has held that a person claiming Indian citizenship cannot be deported as a foreign national without following a fair, lawful and reasoned procedure to determine their nationality, even where the authorities dispute the authenticity of the documents produced in support of the citizenship claim. The Court clarified that although the burden of establishing Indian citizenship rests upon the person asserting such a right, the authorities cannot bypass procedural safeguards or order deportation without first providing an adequate opportunity to establish the claim.
Justice C.M. Poonacha, while deciding a writ petition filed by Abdul Rahim, directed the authorities not to deport or repatriate him until the question of his nationality was determined through the procedure prescribed under law. The Court emphasised that the constitutional protections guaranteed under Articles 14 and 21 extend to every person, including foreign nationals, and that the power to regulate the movement of suspected foreigners cannot be equated with an unrestricted power to deport individuals whose nationality remains disputed.
The dispute arose after Rahim was apprehended by officials of the Parappana Agrahara Police Station during a special drive conducted to identify suspected illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. Subsequently, the Foreigners Regional Registration Officer (FRRO), Bengaluru, passed an order dated March 5, 2026, restricting his movement and directing him to remain at Utile Foundation, Kothanur, Bengaluru, until his repatriation.
Rahim challenged the movement restriction order before the Karnataka High Court, contending that he was an Indian citizen by birth and had been residing in India throughout his life. According to his case, he was born on April 14, 1979, at New Seemapuri in Delhi and subsequently moved to Bengaluru in 2014, where he was engaged in waste management and scrap trading activities.
To substantiate his claim of Indian citizenship, Rahim relied upon several government-issued documents, including a birth certificate, passport, voter identity card, Aadhaar card, PAN card, driving licence and an identity card issued by the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP).
He maintained that the authorities had treated him as a foreign national without first examining his documents through an appropriate legal process or giving him a reasonable opportunity to explain the discrepancies allegedly identified in the records.
An additional aspect of the dispute concerned Rahim’s previous criminal proceedings under the Foreigners Act, 1946. In June 2012, a Sessions Court in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, had convicted him in a case involving the allegation that he was a Bangladeshi national. He challenged the conviction before the Allahabad High Court, which granted him bail in July 2012. His criminal appeal against the conviction continues to remain pending.
Rahim argued that the executive authorities could not disregard the judicial order granting him bail and subsequently curtail his liberty through an administrative direction without following the applicable legal procedure.
The authorities, however, disputed his claim of Indian citizenship and alleged that he was a Bangladeshi national who had relied upon forged or fabricated documents to obtain Indian identity records.
The controversy required the High Court to examine the scope of the powers available to immigration authorities under the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, and the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025. It also raised important constitutional questions concerning the distinction between the rights available exclusively to Indian citizens and the fundamental protections that extend to all persons within the territory of India.
In particular, the Court was required to consider whether an individual could be deported merely on the basis of the authorities’ suspicion regarding his nationality, or whether a proper determination supported by a fair opportunity of hearing was necessary before such a serious consequence could follow.
The judgment is significant because it recognises that the power of the State to regulate the presence and movement of foreign nationals must operate within the framework of constitutional guarantees. Even where a person’s citizenship claim is disputed, the authorities remain obligated to follow a lawful process before removing that individual from the country.
Arguments of the Parties:
Appearing for Abdul Rahim, Advocate Clifton D. Rozario, instructed by Advocate Maitreyi Krishnan, submitted that the petitioner was an Indian citizen by birth and that his claim was supported by several official documents issued by different government authorities.
It was argued that Rahim was born on April 14, 1979, in New Seemapuri, Delhi, and had subsequently moved to Bengaluru in 2014. He had been engaged in waste management and scrap trading activities and was residing in India with his family.
Counsel submitted that the petitioner possessed a birth certificate, passport, voter identity card, Aadhaar card, PAN card, driving licence and BBMP identity card. According to him, these documents demonstrated that Rahim had consistently asserted his Indian identity and had maintained a long-standing connection with the country.
The petitioner’s principal objection was that the FRRO had issued the movement restriction order without first undertaking a proper determination of his nationality. He contended that the authorities had proceeded on the assumption that he was a Bangladeshi national merely because his citizenship documents were disputed.
It was submitted that the authorities could not treat allegations of document fabrication as conclusive proof of foreign nationality without examining the material relied upon by the petitioner and providing him an opportunity to explain the alleged discrepancies.
Counsel also drew attention to the previous criminal proceedings under the Foreigners Act, 1946. Rahim had been convicted by the Sessions Court in Ghaziabad in June 2012, but his appeal against the conviction was pending before the Allahabad High Court, which had granted him bail in July 2012.
The petitioner argued that the authorities could not disregard the judicial order granting him bail and impose restrictions affecting his liberty through an executive order without following the procedure established by law.
Another important submission concerned the consequences of the movement restriction order on Rahim’s family and livelihood. It was submitted that he was the primary earning member of his family, consisting of his wife and infant child. By directing him to remain at Utile Foundation, the authorities had effectively prevented him from pursuing his regular occupation and earning a livelihood.
The petitioner therefore sought judicial intervention against the movement restriction order and protection from deportation until his claim of Indian citizenship was properly examined.
On the other hand, Additional Solicitor General K. Aravind Kamath, assisted by Additional Government Advocate Shiva Reddy, appearing for the authorities, strongly disputed Rahim’s claim of Indian citizenship.
The authorities maintained that Rahim was a Bangladeshi national who had attempted to establish an Indian identity through forged and fabricated documents. According to their case, the documents relied upon by the petitioner contained serious discrepancies that undermined their authenticity.
Particular emphasis was placed on the birth certificate produced by Rahim, which recorded that he had been born in April 1979 at Guru Gobind Singh Government Hospital in Delhi.
The authorities pointed out that the hospital had been established only in December 1995, whereas the birth certificate purportedly recorded a birth that had taken place approximately sixteen years earlier. They argued that this chronological inconsistency raised serious doubts about the genuineness of the certificate.
The authorities also questioned the authenticity of the death certificate of Rahim’s father, submitting that the relevant details could not be verified from the records maintained by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi.
On this basis, the State contended that the petitioner had relied upon fabricated documents to secure other identity documents and that the existence of such records could not automatically establish his Indian citizenship.
The authorities therefore argued that Rahim’s claim deserved rejection and that the writ petition was liable to be dismissed.
The central disagreement between the parties thus concerned not merely the authenticity of individual documents but also the procedure that the authorities were required to follow before treating the petitioner as a foreign national and proceeding with his deportation.
Court’s Judgment:
The Karnataka High Court partly accepted the petitioner’s challenge and held that although the authorities possessed statutory powers to regulate the movement and residence of foreigners, deportation could not be undertaken without first determining the person’s nationality through a fair and lawful procedure.
Justice C.M. Poonacha examined the provisions of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, along with the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025, and considered the constitutional protections available to individuals whose nationality is disputed.
The Court recognised that the Constitution distinguishes between rights available exclusively to citizens and fundamental rights that extend to every person, irrespective of citizenship.
Article 19 of the Constitution guarantees certain freedoms, including the right to move freely throughout the territory of India and reside and settle in any part of the country. These rights are available exclusively to Indian citizens.
However, Articles 14 and 21 extend their protection to all persons. Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws, while Article 21 provides that no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.
The distinction was particularly relevant because the authorities had questioned Rahim’s citizenship and treated him as a foreign national. The Court clarified that even if a person is ultimately found to be a foreigner, the constitutional protections under Articles 14 and 21 cannot be denied.
Consequently, the State cannot remove an individual from the country merely on the basis of suspicion or an unverified conclusion regarding nationality. The process leading to deportation must satisfy the requirements of fairness, legality and reasoned decision-making.
Citizenship claim must be examined through a fair procedure
The High Court examined the documents produced by Rahim in support of his claim of Indian citizenship. It particularly took note of his voter identity card, which had been issued in December 2005, and his passport, issued in June 2018.
The Court observed that the issuance of a passport indicated that some process of verification had been undertaken by the concerned authorities. Although the existence of such documents did not conclusively establish citizenship, they were relevant materials that required consideration before any decision concerning deportation could be taken.
The Court observed:
“The said documents clearly indicate that the petitioner has been residing in India for a considerably long period of time, throughout the period of which the petitioner has consistently asserted that he was an Indian citizen.”
The Court therefore considered that Rahim’s claim could not be rejected merely by examining the alleged discrepancy in his birth certificate in isolation from the other documents produced by him.
The authorities had questioned the birth certificate because the hospital mentioned in it was reportedly established only in December 1995, whereas the document recorded a birth in April 1979.
The High Court did not treat this discrepancy as irrelevant. However, it held that the existence of such an objection did not eliminate the obligation of the authorities to examine the other materials relied upon by the petitioner and provide him an opportunity to explain his case.
The Court emphasised that where a person asserts Indian citizenship by birth and produces multiple documents in support of the claim, the authorities must undertake a proper examination before concluding that the person is a foreign national.
It observed:
“Since the petitioner is asserting that he is an Indian citizen by birth and is relying upon various documents in support of the same, the respondent – authorities ought to have afforded an opportunity to the petitioner and a fair process ought to have been undertaken to adjudicate the aspect regarding the assertion of citizenship by the petitioner by considering the various documents relied upon by him before any order is passed, whereunder the petitioner is sought to be removed from India.”
The observation makes it clear that the burden of establishing citizenship and the obligation to follow a fair procedure are separate legal considerations. Even where the burden rests upon the individual to substantiate his claim, the authorities cannot dispense with the requirement of examining the evidence through a lawful process.
Burden of proving citizenship does not eliminate procedural safeguards
One of the important aspects of the judgment is the Court’s clarification that the burden of establishing Indian citizenship rests upon the person making such a claim.
The Court did not hold that the production of Aadhaar, PAN, voter identity cards or passports automatically establishes Indian citizenship. Nor did it accept the petitioner’s claim as conclusively proved merely because he possessed several government-issued documents.
Instead, the Court recognised that the authorities were entitled to question the authenticity and legal significance of the documents and determine whether the petitioner satisfied the requirements of Indian citizenship.
However, that determination must take place through a fair, lawful and reasoned procedure.
The distinction is important because the existence of official identity documents and the legal status of citizenship are not necessarily identical. A document may establish identity, residence or participation in an administrative process without independently determining citizenship under the applicable law.
At the same time, where such documents are relied upon to substantiate a citizenship claim, the authorities cannot ignore them without proper consideration.
The Court therefore required the authorities to provide Rahim with an opportunity to present and explain the documents before reaching a conclusion concerning his nationality.
Power to restrict movement is distinct from power to deport
The High Court also examined the legality of the movement restriction order passed by the FRRO on March 5, 2026.
The petitioner had contended that the authorities lacked the legal power to require him to remain at Utile Foundation in Bengaluru. However, the Court rejected this particular submission.
Referring to Section 7(2)(f)(ii) of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, the Court held that the statutory provision empowered the authorities to require a person to reside at a particular place.
Accordingly, the direction requiring Rahim to remain at Utile Foundation could not be considered entirely without statutory authority.
This finding is important because the Court distinguished between the power to regulate the movement or residence of a suspected foreign national and the separate question of whether that person could lawfully be deported.
The existence of statutory authority to impose movement restrictions does not automatically establish that the person concerned is a foreign national or that deportation can immediately follow.
In other words, the authorities may exercise the powers conferred by the 2025 legislation, but the exercise of those powers must remain consistent with the applicable procedural safeguards.
The Court therefore did not invalidate the movement restriction order merely because it required Rahim to remain at a specified facility. Its principal concern was that the authorities could not proceed with deportation without a proper determination of his nationality.
Earlier criminal conviction and pending appeal
The High Court also took note of the petitioner’s previous conviction under the Foreigners Act, 1946, and the appeal pending before the Allahabad High Court.
Rahim had been convicted by a Sessions Court in Ghaziabad in June 2012 on the allegation that he was a Bangladeshi national. Subsequently, the Allahabad High Court granted him bail in July 2012, and his appeal against the conviction continued to remain pending.
The Karnataka High Court observed that the movement restriction order passed by the FRRO did not refer to the earlier conviction or the pending criminal appeal.
Instead, the order proceeded on the premise that Rahim was a foreign national without adequately addressing the relevant background or undertaking the required determination of nationality.
The Court also noted that the FRRO had examined the documents produced by Rahim only after the movement restriction order had been issued and during the pendency of the writ petition.
Such an examination, the Court held, could not be treated as an adjudication of nationality in accordance with the procedure contemplated under the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025.
The question of whether a person is a foreigner must be determined through the procedure prescribed under the applicable legal framework. An administrative examination of documents undertaken after passing a restrictive order cannot automatically substitute the required legal determination.
The Court’s observations do not amount to setting aside the earlier conviction or deciding the pending criminal appeal before the Allahabad High Court. Rather, they address the independent requirement that the authorities must follow the applicable legal procedure before taking steps to remove the petitioner from India.
Deportation stayed until nationality is determined
After examining the statutory framework, constitutional safeguards and documents produced by Rahim, the High Court concluded that his deportation could not proceed until the authorities completed the necessary steps to determine his nationality.
The Court held that the authorities were required to give him an adequate opportunity to establish his claim of Indian citizenship and consider the documents relied upon before reaching a final conclusion.
Accordingly, it directed:
“Till the further steps as regards the nationality of the petitioner is undertaken by the concerned authorities the repatriation / deportation of the petitioner shall not be undertaken by the concerned authorities.”
The direction protects Rahim against deportation while the nationality determination remains pending. It does not, however, declare him to be an Indian citizen or permanently prevent the authorities from taking action under the applicable immigration laws.
If the authorities determine, after following the prescribed procedure and providing an adequate opportunity of hearing, that he is a foreign national, they may proceed in accordance with law.
The judgment ultimately draws an important distinction between the State’s legitimate authority to identify and regulate foreign nationals and its constitutional obligation to ensure that no person is deprived of liberty or removed from the country through an unfair process.
By directing the authorities to complete the nationality determination before deportation, the Karnataka High Court reaffirmed that executive powers under immigration legislation must be exerc