Introduction:
The Gauhati High Court has clarified that disciplinary proceedings against civilian members of the Border Roads Organisation (BRO) do not necessarily require consultation with the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC), where the exemption provided under Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958, applies. The Court held that civilian members of the BRO fall within the category of Defence Service (Civilian) for the purpose of the relevant exemption and, consequently, the disciplinary authority was not required to seek the UPSC’s advice before imposing punishment.
The ruling was delivered by Justice Nchumbemo Mozhui while deciding a writ petition filed by Kishori Saw under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The petitioner sought to challenge the memorandum of charges issued against him in 2012, the departmental enquiry report and the punishment order dated November 27, 2015. He also sought consequential service benefits arising from the alleged illegality of the disciplinary proceedings.
The dispute arose from an incident involving the alleged mishandling of explosives by personnel serving under the petitioner. At the relevant time, Kishori Saw was posted as Officer Commanding of the 51 Road Construction Company at Leh, Jammu and Kashmir. Following the incident, departmental proceedings were initiated against him in connection with the alleged lapses in the handling of explosives by personnel working under his command.
After completion of the departmental enquiry, the disciplinary authority concluded that the charges against the petitioner were partially proved. On the basis of that finding, a penalty of withholding three increments without cumulative effect was imposed through an order dated November 27, 2015.
The petitioner questioned the legality of the proceedings, primarily on the ground that the authorities had failed to follow the applicable guidelines issued by the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT). According to him, the enquiry report, along with his representation against the findings, ought to have been forwarded to the UPSC for its advice before the disciplinary authority reached a final decision.
The controversy therefore required the High Court to examine the relationship between the procedural requirements under the DoPT guidelines and the exemption from UPSC consultation provided under the 1958 Regulations. It also required consideration of the status of civilian personnel serving in the BRO and the effect of the Ministry of Defence’s clarification concerning the applicability of the exemption to serving General Reserve Engineer Force (GREF) officers.
Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958, provides an exemption from consultation with the Commission in disciplinary matters affecting persons belonging to Defence Service (Civilian). The respondents relied on this provision to contend that the petitioner’s service in the BRO brought him within the exempted category.
The Ministry of Defence Office Memorandum dated October 24, 2019, also assumed significance. It clarified that Regulation 5(2) would apply to serving GREF officers of the BRO in disciplinary proceedings conducted under the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965. The High Court examined this clarification alongside the constitutional position of civilian members of the BRO and the circumstances in which the departmental proceedings had been initiated.
Ultimately, the Court concluded that the exemption under Regulation 5(2) applied to the petitioner and that consultation with the UPSC was not mandatory in his case. It accordingly declined to interfere with the departmental proceedings, the enquiry report or the punishment order.
Arguments of the Parties:
The petitioner’s principal challenge was directed against the procedural validity of the departmental proceedings. Kishori Saw contended that the authorities had not complied with the applicable DoPT guidelines, particularly the Office Memorandums dated May 10, 2011, and March 5, 2014. According to him, these instructions prescribed an important procedural safeguard in disciplinary matters involving consultation with the UPSC.
The petitioner argued that the enquiry report could not simply be acted upon by the disciplinary authority without following the prescribed procedure. He maintained that the enquiry report, together with his representation against the findings, should have been forwarded to the UPSC for its advice. The advice obtained from the Commission was then required to be communicated to him so that he could submit his representation before the disciplinary authority took its final decision.
His grievance was therefore not confined to disagreement with the findings of the enquiry officer. Rather, he questioned the decision-making process itself, asserting that the failure to obtain and communicate the UPSC’s advice amounted to non-compliance with the applicable administrative instructions.
The petitioner also relied upon the nature of the departmental proceedings and the role played by the Army authorities in relation to the BRO and GREF. The issue was relevant because the respondents relied on the petitioner’s connection with the Defence establishment to invoke the exemption under the 1958 Regulations. However, the petitioner sought to challenge the disciplinary action on the basis of the procedural requirements governing departmental enquiries.
The DoPT guidelines formed an important part of his case. The High Court itself acknowledged that the Office Memorandum dated May 10, 2011, was statutory in nature and that compliance with it was mandatory. The petitioner’s contention was that the prescribed procedure had not been followed, particularly in relation to forwarding the enquiry report and his representation to the UPSC.
On the other hand, the respondents defended the disciplinary proceedings by relying primarily on Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958. They submitted that the provision expressly exempts the Government from consulting the UPSC in disciplinary matters affecting a person belonging to Defence Service (Civilian).
According to the respondents, the petitioner was a civilian member of the BRO and fell within the category covered by the exemption. Consequently, the requirement of obtaining the Commission’s advice did not arise in his case. They maintained that the petitioner’s status within the BRO and its connection with the Armed Forces brought the disciplinary proceedings within the scope of the relevant regulatory provision.
The respondents further relied on the Ministry of Defence Office Memorandum dated October 24, 2019. The memorandum clarified that Regulation 5(2) of the 1958 Regulations was applicable to serving GREF officers of the BRO in disciplinary proceedings conducted under the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
This clarification was relied upon to establish that civilian personnel serving in the BRO were covered by the exemption and that UPSC consultation was not required merely because disciplinary proceedings were being conducted under the ordinary civil service disciplinary framework.
The respondents also relied on the distinction between departmental disciplinary action and proceedings under the Army Act. Although the Army authorities exercised control in relation to the BRO and GREF, the action taken against the petitioner was a departmental proceeding. The authorities had merely recommended the initiation of departmental proceedings and had not recommended court-martial proceedings against him.
The respondents therefore maintained that the disciplinary action had been taken through the applicable departmental mechanism and that the absence of UPSC consultation did not invalidate the proceedings. On this basis, they opposed the petitioner’s request to set aside the enquiry report and punishment order.
Court’s Judgment:
The Gauhati High Court examined the competing submissions by considering the nature of the petitioner’s service, the applicability of the DoPT instructions and, most importantly, the exemption provided under Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958.
At the outset, the Court acknowledged the significance of the procedural guidelines issued by the Department of Personnel and Training. It observed that the DoPT Office Memorandum dated May 10, 2011, was statutory in nature and that compliance with its requirements was mandatory. The Court also noted the procedural position concerning the enquiry report and the representation submitted by the petitioner.
In this regard, the Court observed that the enquiry report, together with the petitioner’s representation, ought to have been forwarded to the UPSC for its advice and that the advice should thereafter have been furnished to the petitioner to enable him to submit his representation.
This observation recognised the importance of procedural fairness in disciplinary proceedings. Where consultation with the UPSC is required under the applicable framework, the prescribed procedure cannot be treated as an empty formality. The concerned employee must also be afforded the opportunity contemplated by the applicable instructions to respond to the advice before the disciplinary authority reaches its final decision.
However, the Court did not treat the procedural requirements under the DoPT guidelines as automatically establishing that UPSC consultation was compulsory in every disciplinary matter involving a BRO officer. The decisive question was whether the petitioner belonged to a category expressly exempted from such consultation under the 1958 Regulations.
The Court accordingly examined Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958. The provision exempts the Government from consulting the UPSC in disciplinary matters affecting a person belonging to Defence Service (Civilian).
The expression and scope of this exemption were central to the dispute. The petitioner was serving as a civilian member of the BRO, and the respondents maintained that his service status brought him within the category of Defence Service (Civilian). The Court accepted this position after considering the constitutional and administrative framework governing the organisation.
Justice Nchumbemo Mozhui observed that the petitioner, being a civilian member of the BRO, was also a member of the Armed Forces within the meaning of Article 33 of the Constitution of India. The Court further considered that the BRO came under the Ministry of Defence in 2015 and held that Regulation 5(2) squarely applied to the petitioner.
The Court stated:
“As such, that the petitioner being a Civilian Members of the BRO, is also members of the Armed Forces within the meaning of Article 33 of the Constitution of India and the BRO came under the Ministry of Defence only 2015, the provision of Regulation Clause 5 (2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958 squarely applies to the petitioner and there is no necessity for consultation with the UPSC.”
This finding was significant because it addressed the petitioner’s status not merely by reference to the civilian nature of his employment, but also by considering his position within the BRO and its relationship with the Armed Forces. The Court held that being a civilian employee did not, by itself, take him outside the category of Defence Service (Civilian) for the purpose of the exemption.
The Court also considered the Ministry of Defence Office Memorandum dated October 24, 2019. The memorandum clarified the applicability of Regulation 5(2) to serving GREF officers of the BRO in disciplinary proceedings initiated under the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
The clarification was relevant because the petitioner’s disciplinary proceedings had been conducted through the departmental mechanism. The fact that the proceedings were governed by the CCS (CCA) Rules did not, in the Court’s view, exclude the operation of the exemption under the 1958 Regulations. The Ministry of Defence memorandum specifically addressed the position of serving GREF officers and confirmed that the exemption applied to such disciplinary proceedings.
The Court thus considered the regulatory provision together with the subsequent administrative clarification. It accepted that the petitioner’s position as a civilian member of the BRO brought him within the scope of the exemption and that the authorities were not required to consult the UPSC before imposing the departmental penalty.
Another important aspect of the judgment concerned the role of the Army authorities in relation to the BRO and GREF. The petitioner had questioned the disciplinary action in the context of the control exercised by the Army authorities over the organisation. The Court clarified that the existence of such control did not mean that the proceedings against the petitioner were proceedings under the Army Act or that the matter necessarily involved a court-martial.
The Court observed that the Army authorities were indeed controlling authorities insofar as the BRO and GREF were concerned. However, it emphasised that, in the facts of the case, the authorities had merely recommended the initiation of departmental proceedings against the petitioner. There had been no recommendation for court-martial proceedings under the procedure prescribed by the Army Act and the relevant rules.
The Court stated:
“No doubt the army authorities are also the controlling authorities insofar as BRO and GREF is concerned, however, in the facts of the present proceedings, the authority merely recommended initiation of departmental proceedings against the petitioner. There was no recommendation for court-martial proceedings against the writ petitioner as per the procedure prescribed under the Army Act read with the rules.”
This distinction was important in determining the legal character of the action taken against the petitioner. The proceedings were departmental in nature and had resulted in a penalty under the applicable service disciplinary framework. The Court therefore considered the matter on the basis of the relevant rules and the exemption governing consultation with the UPSC, rather than treating it as a court-martial proceeding.
The Court’s reasoning also demonstrates the need to distinguish between the general procedural requirements governing disciplinary proceedings and specific statutory or regulatory exemptions. Although the DoPT guidelines may prescribe mandatory steps in cases where UPSC consultation is required, the applicability of those steps must be examined alongside the provisions that expressly dispense with consultation for particular categories of employees.
In the present case, the Court found that the petitioner fell within the exempted category under Regulation 5(2). Therefore, the procedural requirement of obtaining UPSC advice could not be insisted upon as a condition for the validity of the disciplinary proceedings. The Court’s conclusion rested on the specific status of the petitioner as a civilian member of the BRO and the applicability of the exemption to serving GREF personnel.
The judgment is particularly relevant for civilian personnel serving in organisations connected with the Defence establishment. It clarifies that the description of an employee as a civilian does not necessarily determine whether the employee falls within the category of Defence Service (Civilian) for the purpose of the UPSC exemption. The governing regulatory framework and the employee’s service status must also be considered.
At the same time, the decision does not establish that UPSC consultation can be dispensed with in every disciplinary proceeding involving a BRO employee, irrespective of the employee’s category or the applicable rules. The Court’s conclusion was based on the particular exemption under Regulation 5(2), read with the Ministry of Defence clarification concerning serving GREF officers. The applicability of the exemption must therefore be assessed in light of the relevant service status and governing provisions.
After considering the pleadings, the applicable regulatory framework and the circumstances in which the departmental proceedings had been initiated, the High Court found no sufficient ground to interfere with the disciplinary action.
The Court held that the petitioner was covered by Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958, and that consultation with the UPSC was not necessary in his case. It consequently declined to set aside the memorandum of charges, the enquiry report or the punishment order dated November 27, 2015.
The Court observed that it found no merit in the writ petition seeking interference with the departmental proceedings, the impugned enquiry report and the punishment order, or in the request for consequential relief.
Accordingly, the Gauhati High Court dismissed the writ petition filed by Kishori Saw under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. No order was passed as to costs.
The decision reinforces the distinction between mandatory procedural safeguards and expressly recognised exemptions under service law. While disciplinary authorities must comply with applicable procedural requirements, the necessity of UPSC consultation depends on whether the employee and the proceedings fall within the scope of the governing exemption. In the case of the petitioner, the High Court concluded that his status as a civilian member of the BRO brought him within Regulation 5(2), leaving no requirement to obtain the Commission’s advice before imposing the departmental penalty.