preloader image

Loading...

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

Fair Trial Over Speed: Delhi High Court Rules on Cross-Examination in Riots Case

Fair Trial Over Speed: Delhi High Court Rules on Cross-Examination in Riots Case

Introduction:

In the case of Mohd. Danish v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Anr., the Delhi High Court addressed the balance between ensuring a speedy trial and safeguarding an accused’s fundamental right to a fair trial. The matter pertained to the 2020 North-East Delhi riots, wherein the accused, Mohd. Danish, sought the recall of a prosecution witness for cross-examination. The Court ruled in favor of Danish, emphasizing that while unnecessary adjournments must be avoided, fairness in trial cannot be compromised in the pursuit of expedition.

Arguments of Both Sides:

The petitioner, Mohd. Danish, argued that the prosecution witness, a head constable, had not identified him in his statement recorded under Section 161 of the CrPC but had purportedly done so in his court deposition. Given this discrepancy, Danish contended that his right to cross-examine the witness was crucial. However, since his senior lawyer was unavailable on the scheduled date, the trial court proceeded with the witness’s deposition, effectively closing his opportunity to cross-examine. He thus moved the Delhi High Court, seeking recall of the witness. The prosecution opposed the plea, arguing that the trial court had appropriately denied an adjournment as the matter involved numerous prosecution witnesses, and granting adjournments would unnecessarily delay the proceedings. They further contended that the unavailability of a senior lawyer was not a sufficient ground for seeking an adjournment.

Court’s Judgment:

Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani ruled that the trial court’s refusal to grant a short adjournment for cross-examination was a disproportionate application of procedural efficiency over substantive fairness. The Court reiterated that while prolonged and unwarranted adjournments should not be permitted, denying an accused a reasonable opportunity to cross-examine a key prosecution witness on a critical issue undermines the fairness of the trial. The High Court observed that a day or two of postponement to facilitate proper cross-examination could not be considered unreasonable. Consequently, it allowed Danish a one-time, limited opportunity to cross-examine the head constable at the earliest available date. However, the Court made it clear that no further adjournments would be granted.