Introduction:

The Delhi High Court has underscored the importance of mental health awareness at educational institutions, particularly at the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT). Justice Rajnish Bhatnagar, while addressing a plea related to the deaths of two IIT Delhi students, emphasized the need for faculty and staff to counsel students about balancing academic excellence with mental and physical well-being. The court dismissed the parents’ plea, alleging a conspiracy and caste discrimination, stating that sympathy alone cannot dictate a legal mandate.

Arguments of Both Sides:

Parents of two deceased IIT Delhi students filed a plea alleging murder, conspiracy, and caste discrimination leading to suicide. They sought a CBI investigation and probe into caste-based atrocities at IIT Delhi. The court observed the grieving parents’ plight but dismissed the plea, citing insufficient evidence. Petitioners argued that their sons faced discrimination, while the respondents contended that the allegations lacked corroboration from other SC/ST students.

Court’s Judgement:

Justice Bhatnagar acknowledged the tragedy but refused to issue a mandamus based solely on sentiment. The court stressed the lack of evidence supporting caste discrimination and noted that other SC/ST students reported no such incidents. While recognizing the emotional challenges faced by the parents, the court dismissed the plea, highlighting the need for a holistic view of the case.