Introduction:
The Karnataka High Court has held that a Magistrate tocannot direct an investigation under Section 175(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), without first considering the explanation of the jurisdictional police officer regarding the refusal to register a First Information Report (FIR). The Court clarified that the provision introduces an important procedural requirement that was not expressly contained in its predecessor, Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC).
Justice Suraj Govindaraj, while hearing a petition filed by three individuals seeking to quash criminal proceedings initiated against them, emphasised that the Magistrate must obtain and consider the submissions of the police officer before exercising the power to order an investigation under the newly introduced provision. The Court held that this requirement is mandatory and cannot be treated as a mere procedural formality.
The ruling is significant because it explains the procedural safeguards introduced under the BNSS in relation to private complaints alleging cognizable offences. It also clarifies the distinction between the powers available to Magistrates under the former criminal procedure framework and those prescribed under the new legislation.
The dispute originated from a private complaint filed by the respondent before the jurisdictional Magistrate, alleging that the petitioners had committed offences including cheating, criminal breach of trust, criminal intimidation and other criminal acts. According to the complaint, the matter had been brought to the attention of the police, but the police had allegedly failed to register an FIR or initiate appropriate action.
Following the failure of the police to act, the complainant approached the Magistrate seeking judicial intervention. Acting on the private complaint, the Magistrate passed an order dated March 3, 2025, referring the matter to the police for investigation.
The order was passed by invoking Section 175(3) of the BNSS, which empowers a Magistrate to direct an investigation into a cognizable offence in circumstances where the statutory requirements are satisfied. The provision substantially corresponds to Section 156(3) of the CrPC, which earlier empowered Magistrates to direct the police to investigate cognizable offences.
However, the three accused individuals challenged the Magistrate’s order before the Karnataka High Court. Their principal objection was that the Magistrate had exercised the power under Section 175(3) without first hearing the jurisdictional police officer regarding the reasons for not registering the FIR.
The petitioners argued that the new provision expressly requires the Magistrate to consider the submissions of the police officer before issuing an investigation direction. Since this requirement had not been followed, they contended that the order dated March 3, 2025, was legally unsustainable.
While examining the issue, the High Court relied upon the Supreme Court’s decision in Om Prakash Ambadkar v. State of Maharashtra and Others, which considered the changes introduced by Section 175(3) of the BNSS in comparison with Section 156(3) of the CrPC.
The Supreme Court’s ruling highlighted that the new provision incorporates additional procedural safeguards, including the requirement that the Magistrate consider the submissions of the police officer before directing an investigation.
The Karnataka High Court applied this legal position to the facts of the case and concluded that the Magistrate had failed to comply with the mandatory requirement. Consequently, it set aside the impugned order and remanded the matter to the Magistrate for fresh consideration in accordance with law.
The Court also directed its Registrar General to circulate a copy of the Supreme Court’s judgment to all Magistrates dealing with private complaints so that the procedural requirements under Section 175(3) of the BNSS are properly followed.
Arguments of the Parties:
The three petitioners approached the Karnataka High Court challenging the criminal proceedings initiated against them following the Magistrate’s direction for police investigation. Their primary contention was that the order referring the private complaint to the police had been passed without following the mandatory procedure prescribed under Section 175(3) of the BNSS.
The petitioners submitted that the complainant had initially approached the jurisdictional police with allegations of cheating, criminal breach of trust, criminal intimidation and other offences. Since the police allegedly failed to register an FIR, the complainant subsequently approached the Magistrate through a private complaint.
According to the petitioners, the Magistrate was required to follow the specific procedure prescribed under the BNSS before directing an investigation. They argued that the provision does not confer an unrestricted power upon the Magistrate to refer every private complaint to the police merely because the complainant alleges that the police have failed to take action.
Their challenge primarily rested on the distinction between Section 156(3) of the CrPC and Section 175(3) of the BNSS. While the earlier provision empowered a Magistrate to order an investigation, the corresponding provision under the new legislation incorporates an express requirement concerning the consideration of the police officer’s explanation for refusing to register an FIR.
The petitioners maintained that the Magistrate could not exercise jurisdiction under Section 175(3) without first obtaining the relevant explanation from the officer in charge of the police station and applying judicial mind to the reasons provided.
They further relied upon the Supreme Court’s decision in Om Prakash Ambadkar v. State of Maharashtra and Others, submitting that the judgment had clearly recognised the additional procedural requirement introduced under the BNSS.
According to them, the Magistrate’s failure to hear the police officer rendered the order dated March 3, 2025, procedurally defective. Consequently, the investigation initiated pursuant to that direction could not be sustained without reconsideration of the complaint in accordance with the statutory procedure.
The petitioners therefore sought interference by the High Court and requested that the criminal proceedings arising from the Magistrate’s order be quashed.
On the other hand, the respondent complainant’s case originated from allegations that the petitioners had committed various criminal offences, including cheating, criminal breach of trust and criminal intimidation. The complainant had approached the jurisdictional police seeking action, but the alleged failure of the police to register an FIR led to the filing of a private complaint before the Magistrate.
The complainant consequently sought an investigation into the allegations through judicial intervention. The Magistrate accepted the request and referred the matter to the police under Section 175(3) of the BNSS.
The challenge before the High Court, however, was not confined to the merits of the allegations made in the private complaint. The central question concerned whether the Magistrate had complied with the procedure required under the new provision before directing the police to investigate.
The case summary does not record any detailed independent submissions advanced by the respondent concerning the interpretation of Section 175(3). Nevertheless, the respondent’s underlying position was reflected in the request for investigation based on the allegation that the police had failed to act on the original complaint.
The High Court was therefore required to determine whether the Magistrate’s order could legally stand in the absence of an opportunity being provided to the jurisdictional police officer to explain the reasons for not registering the FIR.
Court’s Judgment:
The Karnataka High Court allowed the petitioners’ challenge to the Magistrate’s order, holding that the requirement of considering the police officer’s explanation under Section 175(3) of the BNSS is mandatory. Justice Suraj Govindaraj observed that the provision introduced an important procedural distinction from the corresponding provision under the earlier Code of Criminal Procedure.
The Court examined the statutory framework governing the power of Magistrates to direct police investigations and relied upon the Supreme Court’s decision in Om Prakash Ambadkar v. State of Maharashtra and Others to understand the legislative changes introduced by the BNSS.
Under the earlier criminal procedure framework, Section 156(3) of the CrPC empowered a Magistrate to order an investigation into a cognizable offence. The provision enabled a person whose complaint had not been acted upon by the police to approach the Magistrate and seek an appropriate direction for investigation.
The Magistrate’s power under Section 156(3) was an important judicial safeguard against police inaction. It enabled the Magistrate to ensure that allegations disclosing cognizable offences were appropriately investigated rather than allowing a complaint to remain unattended merely because the police had declined to register an FIR.
However, the BNSS introduced a revised statutory framework through Section 175(3), incorporating additional procedural requirements before the Magistrate exercises this power.
Section 175(3) provides for a Magistrate empowered under Section 210 to order an investigation in the circumstances specified under the provision. It requires the Magistrate to consider an application supported by an affidavit made under Section 173(4), make such inquiry as considered necessary, and consider the submissions of the police officer concerned regarding the refusal to register an FIR before passing an appropriate direction.
The provision also requires the Magistrate to take into consideration the submissions made by the police officer before deciding whether an investigation should be ordered.
The Karnataka High Court particularly emphasised the significance of this additional requirement. It observed that the new provision does not merely reproduce the earlier power under Section 156(3) of the CrPC but introduces a specific procedural obligation concerning the police officer’s explanation.
The Court noted:
“One of the changes is a specific requirement for consideration and submission of the officer in charge of the police station as regards the refusal to register a FIR before issuing any direction under Section 175(3) of BNSS.”
The Court explained that this requirement has to be followed whenever a private complaint is presented before the Magistrate on the ground that the jurisdictional police have failed to act on the complaint.
It further observed:
“Post the coming into force of the BNSS, if a private complaint were to be filed before the Magistrate on account of the criminal complaint filed before the jurisdictional police not having been acted upon, it is mandatory for the Magistrate to hear the submission of the jurisdictional police officer as to why the registration of the FIR was refused in the first place and thereafter apply his mind and consider whether the matter is required to be referred to investigation or not.”
The observation makes it clear that the Magistrate cannot mechanically forward a private complaint to the police merely because the complainant alleges that an FIR was not registered.
Instead, the Magistrate must first obtain the explanation of the concerned police officer and examine the reasons behind the refusal. Thereafter, the Magistrate must independently assess the material and determine whether the circumstances justify an order directing investigation.
The requirement serves an important procedural purpose. It ensures that the Magistrate considers both the complainant’s grievance and the police officer’s explanation before exercising judicial discretion. This provides an opportunity to examine whether the police failed to act without justification or whether there were reasons that required consideration before an investigation could be ordered.
The Court’s interpretation also reflects the broader legislative objective of introducing additional procedural safeguards under the BNSS. The requirement of hearing the police officer ensures that an investigation direction is not issued without considering the circumstances in which the original complaint was handled.
At the same time, the provision does not take away the Magistrate’s authority to direct an investigation. Rather, it regulates the manner in which that authority must be exercised. The Magistrate retains the power to order an investigation where the facts and circumstances justify such a direction, but that decision must follow the procedure expressly prescribed by the legislature.
The distinction between Sections 156(3) CrPC and 175(3) BNSS is therefore particularly important. While both provisions empower a Magistrate to direct an investigation into a cognizable offence, the latter expressly incorporates the requirement of considering the police officer’s submissions concerning the refusal to register an FIR.
The Supreme Court’s decision in Om Prakash Ambadkar was central to the High Court’s reasoning. By referring to that judgment, the Court reinforced that the procedural changes introduced by the BNSS cannot be ignored merely because the new provision substantially corresponds to an earlier provision of the CrPC.
The statutory language must be given effect, and Magistrates exercising jurisdiction under the BNSS are required to follow the additional safeguards incorporated by Parliament.
Applying these principles to the present case, the High Court found that the Magistrate had referred the private complaint to the police through the order dated March 3, 2025, without first hearing the jurisdictional police officer regarding the reasons for not registering the FIR.
Since the mandatory procedural requirement had not been complied with, the order could not be sustained.
The High Court consequently set aside the Magistrate’s order and remanded the matter for fresh consideration. This means that the Magistrate will have to reconsider the complaint by following the procedure prescribed under Section 175(3) of the BNSS, including obtaining and considering the police officer’s explanation before deciding whether an investigation should be directed.
Importantly, the High Court’s decision does not amount to a determination that the allegations against the petitioners are false or that no criminal investigation can be conducted. The Court interfered with the Magistrate’s order because of a procedural violation and directed reconsideration in accordance with the law.
The Court also took an important institutional step to ensure that the legal position is followed uniformly. It directed the Registrar General to forward a copy of the Supreme Court’s judgment in Om Prakash Ambadkar v. State of Maharashtra and Others to all Magistrates dealing with private complaints.
This direction is significant because Section 175(3) of the BNSS is regularly invoked by complainants seeking judicial intervention when the police allegedly refuse to register an FIR. Ensuring that Magistrates are aware of the additional statutory requirement would help prevent similar procedural errors in future proceedings.
The ruling reinforces that judicial powers must be exercised in accordance with the procedure established by law. Even where a complainant alleges police inaction, the Magistrate cannot overlook the specific safeguards introduced under the BNSS.
Ultimately, the Karnataka High Court clarified that hearing the jurisdictional police officer is a mandatory prerequisite before directing an investigation under Section 175(3) of the BNSS. By setting aside the Magistrate’s order and remanding the matter for fresh consideration, the Court underscored the importance of procedural compliance, judicial application of mind and adherence to the legislative changes introduced through the new criminal procedure framework.