preloader image

Loading...

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

Emotional Bond Cannot Legalise Illegal Adoption: Telangana High Court Refuses Custody in Child Trafficking Probe

Emotional Bond Cannot Legalise Illegal Adoption: Telangana High Court Refuses Custody in Child Trafficking Probe

Introduction:

In a significant and socially sensitive judgment, the High Court of Telangana has reaffirmed that compassion, emotional attachment, and good intentions cannot override statutory safeguards meant to protect children from trafficking and illegal adoption. The case arose when Muthineni Venakanna, the petitioner, approached the High Court seeking restoration of custody of a minor girl child who had been taken away from him and his wife following the registration of a criminal case alleging illegal adoption and child trafficking. The respondents included the State of Telangana, represented by its Principal Secretary, Women and Child Welfare Department, along with police authorities and the Child Welfare Committee. The petitioner and his wife, married since 2014 and childless despite medical efforts, claimed to have adopted a one-month-old girl child in May 2023 through an intermediary and raised her with love and care for nearly two years. However, following complaints of sale and procurement of children, the police registered offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and Sections 80, 81, 87 and 88 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, after which the child was removed from their custody and placed in a Child Protection Centre. Justice T. Madhavi Devi, while dismissing the writ petition, was called upon to decide a critical question: whether custody of a child, allegedly procured through a process not recognised by law and forming part of an ongoing child trafficking investigation, could be restored merely because the child had developed an emotional bond with the adoptive parents. The Court answered this question in the negative, warning that granting such relief would legitimise illegal adoptions and encourage child trafficking.

Arguments:

The petitioner argued that he and his wife had been married for nearly a decade without being blessed with a child despite medical treatment, and that their decision to adopt was driven purely by their desire to give love, care, and a stable family environment to a child. According to the petitioner, in May 2023 they adopted a one-month-old girl child through an intermediary and performed Datha Homam, a traditional Hindu ceremony signifying adoption, after which the child was welcomed into the family with customary rituals such as a cradle ceremony and birthday celebrations. It was contended that from infancy, the child had been nurtured by the petitioner and his wife as their own daughter, receiving emotional warmth, financial security, and proper upbringing. The petitioner submitted that abruptly taking the child away in June 2025 without prior notice had caused severe emotional trauma to both the child and the couple, and that the welfare of the child lay in being restored to the only parents she had known since birth. Emphasis was placed on the principle that the best interests of the child should be paramount, and that institutional care could never replace a loving family environment. To strengthen his case, the petitioner relied upon a Supreme Court order in Dasari Anil Kumar v. Child Welfare Project Director, where custody of a child had been granted to adoptive parents, arguing that a similar compassionate approach ought to be adopted in the present case. The petitioner also contended that mere registration of a criminal case could not justify depriving the child of a stable family life, especially when no final adjudication had yet taken place, and pleaded that he and his wife were willing to comply with any conditions imposed by the Court.

On the other hand, the State strongly opposed the writ petition, submitting that the facts disclosed a clear case of illegal adoption and child trafficking. It was argued that the petitioner and his wife had procured the child through an intermediary by paying consideration, an act expressly prohibited under Section 81 of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, which criminalises the sale and procurement of children for any purpose. The State emphasised that adoptions in India must strictly comply with the statutory framework under the Juvenile Justice Act and the guidelines framed by the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA), which provide the only lawful mechanism for adoption of orphaned, abandoned, or surrendered children. The State submitted that the petitioner had completely bypassed this statutory process, rendering the alleged adoption void and illegal. It was further contended that the intermediary involved was suspected of being part of a larger racket engaged in the sale of children, and that multiple cases had been registered against him, making the present matter far more serious than a mere procedural irregularity. The State distinguished the Supreme Court decision relied upon by the petitioner, pointing out that it was passed in exercise of the Court’s extraordinary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution and was expressly stated not to operate as a precedent. Allowing custody in the present case, the State warned, would send a dangerous signal legitimising illegal adoptions and undermining the national framework designed to combat child trafficking.

Judgment:

After carefully considering the rival submissions, Justice T. Madhavi Devi dismissed the writ petition and refused to direct restoration of custody of the child to the petitioner. The Court held that the foundational fact in the case was that the child had not been adopted through any lawful process recognised under the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, or the CARA guidelines. The Court noted that while the petitioner may have performed religious ceremonies such as Datha Homam and treated the child with affection, such practices have no legal sanctity unless the statutory procedure prescribed by law is followed. Referring specifically to Section 81 of the Juvenile Justice Act, the Court observed that the sale or procurement of a child for any purpose is expressly prohibited and punishable, and that the material on record prima facie indicated that the child had been procured through payment of consideration via an intermediary. The Court underscored that a criminal case had already been registered against the petitioner, his wife, and the intermediary, and that the allegations disclosed a case of child trafficking, which is a grave offence affecting not just individual children but society at large.

Addressing the petitioner’s plea based on emotional bonding, the Court held that while it may be true that the petitioner and his wife took good care of the child, emotional attachment cannot be a ground to regularise or legitimise an illegal adoption. The Court cautioned that granting custody on such a basis would effectively prescribe a parallel, informal route to adoption, thereby encouraging child trafficking and defeating the very purpose of the Juvenile Justice Act and the CARA framework. The Court observed that the Government of India has put in place a comprehensive adoption mechanism precisely to ensure transparency, accountability, and the welfare of children, and any deviation from this process cannot be condoned by judicial sympathy.

The High Court also rejected reliance on the Supreme Court’s order in Dasari Anil Kumar, clarifying that the said order was passed under Article 142 of the Constitution to do complete justice in the peculiar facts of that case and was explicitly declared not to be treated as a precedent. Therefore, the petitioner could not claim similar relief as a matter of right. The Court concluded that where the very foundation of custody is illegal and intertwined with allegations of child trafficking, no relief can be granted under writ jurisdiction, and the welfare of the child must be addressed strictly within the statutory framework. Consequently, the writ petition was dismissed, and the Court declined to interfere with the decision of the authorities placing the child under the care of the Child Welfare Committee.