Introduction:
In a significant development, the Chhattisgarh High Court has ordered a stay on the Civil Judge (Junior Division) Examination 2024, pending the Supreme Court’s decision on the minimum practice requirement for judicial appointments. This decision aligns with similar actions taken by other High Courts across India, awaiting clarity from the apex court.
Background of the Case:
The Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission (CGPSC) had announced the recruitment for 57 Civil Judge (Junior Division) positions on December 23, 2024, with the preliminary examination scheduled for May 18, 2025.
Ms. Vinita Yadav, a law graduate employed full-time with the government, sought to appear for this examination. However, the amended Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, mandated that candidates must be enrolled as advocates under the Advocates Act of 1961. This posed a challenge for Yadav, as full-time government employees are prohibited from enrolling as advocates under Rule 49 of the Bar Council of India Rules.
Arguments Presented:
Petitioner’s Argument:
Ms. Yadav contended that the requirement of advocate enrollment was discriminatory and unjust, effectively barring qualified law graduates engaged in full-time employment from aspiring to judicial positions. She emphasized that her inability to enroll as an advocate was due to statutory restrictions, not a lack of qualification or intent.
State’s Argument:
The Advocate General representing the State of Chhattisgarh informed the court that other High Courts, including those in Karnataka and Gujarat, had already halted their Civil Judge recruitment processes to await the Supreme Court’s ruling on the minimum practice condition. This highlighted a broader national pause on such recruitments pending judicial clarification.
Court’s Observations and Judgment:
The division bench, comprising Justice Ramesh Sinha and Justice Arvind Kumar Verma, acknowledged the gravity of the situation and the necessity for uniformity in judicial recruitment processes across states. Recognizing that the Supreme Court was seized of the matter, the bench directed the CGPSC not to proceed with the scheduled examination until further orders. The court recorded:
“As the Apex Court is seized of the matter, respondent No.2/Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission is directed not to proceed with the examination in question until further orders.”
This decision underscores the judiciary’s commitment to ensuring that recruitment processes are fair, transparent, and in line with the highest judicial standards, pending authoritative guidance from the Supreme Court.