preloader image

Loading...

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

The Legal Affair

Let's talk Law

Telangana High Court Modifies Conviction in Unlawful Assembly Case Due to Lack of Common Object

Telangana High Court Modifies Conviction in Unlawful Assembly Case Due to Lack of Common Object

Introduction:

The Telangana High Court recently delivered a significant judgment in the case of Gandala Laxman vs. The State of Telangana & Batch, reducing the sentences of several individuals convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The Court held that the prosecution failed to establish the existence of a ‘common object’ among the accused, thereby limiting criminal liability to individual actions rather than collective responsibility under Section 149 of the IPC. The Division Bench, comprising Justice K. Surender and Justice E.V. Venugopal, ruled that while Accused No. 1 (A1) and Accused No. 2 (A2) were directly responsible for the fatal attack, the remaining accused could not be held equally culpable for murder.

Arguments of Both Sides:

The prosecution contended that the appellants, along with other villagers from Gouraram Village, participated in an unlawful assembly that led to the death of a forest official during a violent protest over surplus forest land. The complaint, filed shortly after the incident, described how the mob turned aggressive, attacking forest officials and their vehicles. While the initial complaint did not name any individuals, later depositions identified A1 and A2 as the ones who directly assaulted the deceased—A1 with an axe and A2 with a stick. The trial court convicted all accused under Section 302 IPC, relying on Section 149 IPC, which imputes collective guilt on all members of an unlawful assembly when a common object is established.

The defence, led by Advocate R. Prasanth, argued that none of the accused was named in the FIR and that no test identification parade was conducted to establish their involvement. The defence also contended that recoveries made during the investigation did not conclusively link all accused to the crime. Furthermore, they argued that the prosecution failed to establish a prior conspiracy or a shared intent to commit murder, thereby making the conviction under Section 302 IPC untenable for all accused.

Court’s Judgment:

The Telangana High Court scrutinized the evidence and found that the trial court had wrongly presumed a common object among all the accused without substantial proof. Referring to Vijay Pandurang Thakre v. State of Maharashtra, the Court emphasized that a common object must be established through prior planning or conduct during the incident. The Court noted that while A1’s act of striking the deceased with an axe led to the fatal injury, and A2’s assault with a stick contributed to the attack, there was insufficient evidence to hold the other accused responsible for the murder.

The Court upheld the conviction of A1 under Section 302 IPC and maintained his life sentence. However, A2’s conviction was altered from Section 302 to Section 326 IPC (causing grievous hurt with a dangerous weapon), reducing his sentence to five years of imprisonment. For the remaining accused, the Court ruled that their actions constituted voluntary causing hurt under Section 324 IPC, modifying their sentences to three years of imprisonment. The judgment reaffirmed that each accused must be judged based on their role in a crime rather than being held accountable under a blanket conviction due to association with an unlawful assembly.